Omaha Steaks Review

UPDATED September 14. 2020.
This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close

Omaha Steaks is a meat delivery company with a long tradition. It was founded way back in 1917 and it was first named Table Supply Meat Company. By the 1940s, its steaks became famous and they were being served on cross-country trains to the delight of the passengers. In the 1950s, it revolutionized the way meat was sold and marketed by placing ads in magazines, advertising via mail flyers, and sending meat via mail.

In the year of 1966, it got the name by which it is known today: Omaha Steaks. Nowadays, the company ships hundreds of steak products, desserts, and wines throughout North America. It is known for the superior quality of its products and its excellent customer service.

Even though the company ships 14 million pounds of beef per year, every pound is still hand-crafted in-house. Discover its opulent selection of meats, dishes, and wines, explore its pricing, and find out how you can order its famous products in this detailed Omaha Steaks review.

Omaha Steaks screenshoot homepage

How Omaha Steaks Works

With Omaha Steaks, the ordering process is perfectly straightforward. No subscription is required, you can order whenever you wish, and you can pick anything you like from its online shop. There is no minimum order, which means that you can order as much or as little food as you need.

The options before you include beef steaks, other meats, BBQ items, seafood, meals, starters, sides, desserts, and wine. Each of these categories is divided into numerous sections to aid you in your search for the perfect cut, dish, treat or bottle. You can purchase items individually or in money-saving combos.

The company also offers an impressive selection of personal and business gifts for various occasions. You can purchase gift packs and baskets, gift cards or gift plans with monthly, bi-monthly or quarterly deliveries. We will explore all personal shopping and gift options in greater detail in the following sections of this Omaha Steaks review.

Once you select the items you wish to purchase and place your order, you get a confirmation email. You can start tracking your order online an hour after you have placed it. If you are having any troubles whatsoever, you can reach out to the friendly customer support via phone (toll-free) or email.

What Makes Omaha Steaks Different

Omaha Steaks has been around for more than 100 years, which is more than impressive, especially considering that although popular in general, meat delivery services tend to vanish as quickly as they enter the market. It takes a lot to keep up with the competition and Omaha Steaks seems to have what it takes to stay at the very top regardless of the changing market trends.

Omaha Steaks Meals & Occasions

What has allowed this company to maintain its high market position for over a century is its dedication to a fully personal approach that makes it one of America’s most trusted family-owned butcheries. Currently run by the fifth generation of the family that started it all, it may sell millions of pounds of beef alone every year, but every meat product it delivers is aged to perfection and hand-cut by its team of experienced butchers. Its products are the exact opposite of the mass-produced, stale, and flavorless items that sit on the shelves of supermarkets across the country. Its focus on premium-quality, grain-fed, naturally raised, naturally aged, and hand-cut meat is what keeps its customers coming back for more.

As a thank-you to its loyal patrons, the company has launched its Steaklover rewards program. By purchasing its products, watching its videos, and referring friends, you earn reward points that you can exchange for free food, that is, Omaha Steaks’ most popular products.

It is also important to mention that by shopping at Omaha Steaks, you do not only get to earn great rewards, but you also get to help those in need. The company has partnered with numerous charitable organizations and regularly helps them reach their fundraising goals. You can help by purchasing select Omaha Steaks products through the company’s Steaks For Good program. As much as 10% of the value of your purchase goes directly to the organization of your choice.

Omaha Steaks Products

As mentioned previously in this Omaha Steaks review, the company’s offer is divided into 8 main categories, plus gift options. We will now focus on each of them individually and see what you can find in each section of the company’s online shop. The categories include Steaks, Meats, BBQ, Seafood, Meals, Starters & Sides, Desserts, and Wine.

Omaha Steaks steaks

In the Steaks section, you can find dozens of delicious beef cuts, including filet mignons, strip steaks, top sirloins, ribeyes, t-bones, porterhouses, flank steaks, tri-tip steaks, bistro steaks, prime rib, skewers, and tips. You can also get steak entrées, surf & turf combos, specialty and private reserve steaks, and complete steak meals, as well as seasonings, rubs, sauces, and other add-ons that perfectly complement the steaks. We were delighted to see that you can purchase delicious dog treats as well, so your best friend can enjoy a great meal, too. The section mostly includes grain-fed meat, but there is a subsection dedicated to grass-fed beef.

The Meats section was created for people who love everything from chicken to bison. It features about a dozen subsections, including gourmet burgers, franks, brats, sausages, bison, veal, lamb, roasts, poultry, pork, hams, ribs, bacon, steak snacks, beef jerky, and more. You can purchase just meat or opt for entrées, complete meals, and various curated toppers.

The BBQ category can be divided into 2 main subsections, including smoker-ready and ready-to-eat items. You can opt for gameday assortments, steaks, gourmet burgers, franks, brats, sausages, poultry, seafood or pork, all perfect for when you are in the barbecue mood. It is worth noting that this section also includes BBQ tools and accessories, so you do not have to go elsewhere to get everything you need for a great BBQ party.

The Seafood section includes both fish and shellfish. In the fish subsection, you can find salmon, cod, sole, tuna, halibut, tilapia, seabass, Mahi Mahi, swordfish, snapper, haddock, caviar, and more. As far as shellfish goes, you can opt for lobster, shrimp, crab, scallops, clams, mussels, and oyster, all of premium quality, responsibly sourced, and frozen fresh. If you want to save time on prep, you can give seafood entrées and meals a try.

Omaha Steaks Seafood section

The Meals section is huge and you can filter the items by dozens of criteria, from prep type and main protein source to special dietary needs and number of servings. You can opt for steak, chop, seafood, poultry, roast, pasta, burger, rib, sausage, veggie meals, and many others, pick prepared, ready-to-cook or raw meals, cook for 2, 4 or 18 people, and try any cooking method, from pan frying to smoking. The meals come in single-course and multi-course variations, so you can get something tasty to enjoy on workdays or something rich for your dinner parties and special occasions.

In the Starters & Sides section, you can find beef, seafood, and specialty appetizers, appetizer combos, charcuterie, soups, stews, veggie sides, potato sides, specialty sides, and delicious toppers, including mushrooms and blue cheese, smoky bacon jam, Dijon mustard ajoli, and other delectable extras that can make any meal shine.

Desserts are not as numerous as other items, but there are at least 20 decadent options at all times. You can opt for cakes, cheesecakes, pies, tarts, and specialty desserts like crème brulee and decide whether you want to get just a piece or treat yourself to a whole cake.

Omaha Steaks Dessert

If you love good wine, you can pair your meals with bottles of your favorite reds, whites, and sparkling wines available straight through the Omaha Steaks online shop. You can purchase wines individually or in assorted packs and baskets.

Finally, let us say a word or two about the gift options. You can purchase gift foods and wines, gift cards or gift plans.

Gift foods and wines are sorted by occasion, recipient, and gift type. You can opt for wedding, birthday, congratulations or anniversary gifts, get perfect presents for him or her, mom or dad, student or associate, or choose from gift baskets, steaks, desserts, slow cooker meals, dog treats, and more. There is a special section dedicated to business gifts, ranging from employee appreciation gifts to custom business gift programs.

If you want to get a gift that keeps on giving, you can purchase the monthly, bi-monthly or quarterly gift box including hand-picked steaks, seafood, meals or grilling items. If you do not know what to get, a gift card is always a good choice, especially since you can freely decide on the card value.

Pricing

As it is usually the case with services that offer hundreds of products, it is difficult to talk about pricing. However, we will do our best to give you a sense of what you can expect price-wise. Steaks start under $1 per ounce, but the prices can get much higher for private reserve and other luxurious items. Other meats and BBQ items can get as low as $1.50 per 5-ounce package, depending on the meat type you opt for.

Fish filets start at $3.78 per 5-ounce package and they are sold in packages ranging from 4.5 ounces to 2.5 pounds. As expected, shellfish is more expensive, starting at about $1 per ounce.

Omaha Steaks meals prices

Meals normally start at $2.50 per serving for single-course meals. Multi-course meals can cost upward of $15 per person. They are sold in packages of various sizes, going up to 18 servings per pack. Appetizers and sides start at about $1 per piece and you can purchase them individually, in packs or by the pound. The price per serving is lower if you opt for greater quantities.

Desserts can cost as little as $2 per piece and the prices rarely exceed $30 for a whole cake. Individual wines start at about $25, but you can pay significantly less per bottle if you opt for a wine gift basket or gift pack. All gifts start under $50, with the exception of gift plans. The most affordable gift plans cost $69.99 per month.

Omaha Steaks gifts price

Shipping is not free, except on select items like combos and wines. The costs depend on the value of your shipment and your location. Within the continental US, standard shipping costs $17.99 for orders up to $69.99. Orders worth up to $129.99 come with a $19.99 shipping fee and all orders worth more than $129.99 come with a $21.99 shipping fee.

Additional shipping fees apply to boxes sent to Hawaii and Alaska (add $39.99), Puerto Rico (add $39), Canada (add $42.99), and the US Virgin Islands (add $125).

If you opt for faster shipping options, there is an extra shipping surcharge of $19.99 – $49.99, depending on the option you choose. As a company that stands behind its products, Omaha Steaks offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee. If you are not perfectly happy with your shipment, you can always get a replacement or a refund, whichever suits you better.

Delivery Areas

Omaha Steaks does great in terms of geographical coverage. It delivers throughout the United States, Canada, Puerto Rico, and the US Virgin Islands. Shipping options include standard shipping (up to 7 to 10 business days), Express (2-3 business days), Rush (1-2 business days), and Saturday Rush (1-2 business days). The company does not ship to PO boxes.

Omaha Steaks Pros And Cons

To make sure Omaha Steaks meets all your standards and expectations, it is important to know its biggest advantages and disadvantages. With a short overview of its pros and cons, you can easily decide if Omaha Steaks is the right company for you.

Pros
  • Hundreds of meat cuts, meals, appetizers, sides, and desserts
  • Excellent selection of fine wines
  • Vast range of food and wine gifts
  • Great rewards program
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Items for every budget

Cons

  • Steep shipping fees

Bottom Line

Omaha Steaks has everything you need for the ultimate home dining experience, especially if you are a meat lover. From budget to luxurious cuts of all kinds of meat to ready-to-cook and ready-to-eat meals, sides, and desserts, you can get it all at the company’s online shop. Plus, you can get your hands on exclusive wines at good prices, purchase amazing gifts for your loved ones, and even save as you buy with the Steaklovers rewards program.

Everything you purchase comes with a satisfaction guarantee, so you can get your money back in case you are not 100% happy with your order. We only wish the shipping fees were a bit lower since they significantly up the total cost of your shipments. Still, with select free shipping items and discounts on larger quantities, you can save quite a bit. All in all, given the company’s long tradition and impressive product selection, we believe that Omaha Steaks is a service every meat-loving American should try at least once.


Omaha Steaks FAQ

Are Omaha Steaks products any good?

Omaha Steaks provides naturally raised, professionally aged, and hand-crafted steaks. While its selection includes both budget cuts and exclusive Private Reserve items, all products in its online shop are of guaranteed high quality.

Is Omaha Steaks worth it?

Omaha Steaks offers a good value for your money. It provides a neat combination of easy online ordering, home delivery, immense product variety, and fair pricing. Its products come with a satisfaction guarantee, so you only pay for the food you love.

What grade of beef does Omaha Steaks offer?

The company does not state the USDA grade of its beef. However, according to its representatives, the company does have a full-time USDA inspector and its beef could be classified as either Choice or Prime, depending on the cut.

Is Omaha Steaks beef grass-fed?

Omaha Steaks mainly offers grain-fed beef. However, the Steaks section of the Omaha Steaks website also includes a subsection dedicated to grass-fed beef.

Are Omaha Steaks products hormone-free?

The company does not provide information on hormone use. However, its meat is inspected by the USDA and does not contain any unapproved hormones or antibiotics.

Are Omaha Steaks products organic?

No, the company’s products are generally not organic.

How old are my Omaha Steaks?

Omaha Steaks are aged a minimum of 21 days. The company prides itself on its natural aging process that yields full-flavored, perfectly tender beef. The aging process can sometimes takes up to 60 days.

How does Omaha Steaks ship its products?

Omaha Steaks ships its products via UPS. Orders arrive in insulated coolers with plenty of dry ice that keeps the meat frozen during transit. Standard shipping takes up to 10 business days. With faster shipping methods, deliveries arrive in 1-3 days.

Where is Omaha Steaks located?

The company is based in Omaha, Nebraska. It operates retail stores throughout the US.

Who owns Omaha Steaks?

Omaha Steaks is a privately held company founded in 1917 by the Simon family. Today it is owned and operated by the 5th generation of the Simon family.

How do I cook steaks from Omaha Steaks?

First, you should oil up and season your steaks. Then, place them on your grill preheated on high. Check the recommended cooking time based on steak type and thickness. A detailed cooking guide is available on the Omaha Steaks website.

How to cook Omaha Steaks potatoes au gratin?

You can microwave them on high for about 1-3 minutes per portion. Alternatively, you can cook them in an oven or an air fryer for 25-40 minutes. Do not thaw them before cooking. Detailed instructions are provided on the Omaha Steaks website.

How do I cook Omaha Steaks caramel apple tartlets?

Omaha Steaks caramel apple tartlets can be cooked in an oven or a microwave, without previous thawing. In an oven preheated to 400°F, bake your tartlets for about 20 minutes. In a microwave, bake them on high for 60-70 seconds.

How do I cook Omaha Steaks chicken fried steaks?

You can cook Omaha Steaks chicken fried steaks in an oven. Preheat the oven to 400°F, place unthawed steaks on a lined pan, and bake for 12 minutes on each side. If you have an air fryer, you can cook the steaks at 360°F for 8-9 minutes on each side.

How do I cook Omaha Steaks filet mignon?

The Omaha Steaks website features preparation and recipe instructions for all filet mignon products. The company even offers a steak cooking chart and grilling tips that can help you cook your filet mignon to your taste.

How do I cook Omaha Steaks meatballs?

Omaha Steaks meatballs can be cooked in an oven or a microwave. If using an oven, preheat it to 350°F. Place your meatballs on a lined pan and heat for 20 minutes. In a microwave, cook for 2-4 minutes at high heat.

Do Omaha Steaks products come frozen?

Yes, Omaha Steaks products are delivered frozen.

How do I thaw Omaha Steaks products?

Place your vacuum-sealed steaks on a tray in a single layer and pop them into your fridge. Defrosting may take 4-24 hours, depending on the cut. In a hurry, thaw vacuum-sealed steaks in cold water for 15-40 minutes.

How long does Omaha Steaks dry ice last?

Omaha Steaks uses enough dry ice to keep all products frozen during transit, which usually takes up to 48 hours. The company’s dry ice may last longer than 48 hours, but you should place the food in a freezer as soon as you can to avoid defrosting.

How long do Omaha Steaks products last during shipping?

Omaha Steaks uses specially designed packaging that keeps its products frozen for approximately 48 hours during transit in all weather conditions. Its products are guaranteed to arrive in optimal shape.

How long do Omaha Steaks products last in a freezer?

Omaha Steaks products can last up to 3 months in a freezer.

How long are Omaha Steaks products good for?

When stored in a freezer, Omaha Steaks products can last up to 3 months. Products that have been thawed in a refrigerator can be refrozen within 1-2 days. If a product is kept at room temperature for up to 2 hours, it should be cooked immediately.

How much does Omaha Steaks charge for shipping?

Omaha Steaks charges $17.99 to $21.99 for standard shipping within the mainland US. Faster shipping options come with additional fees ranging from $19.99 to $49.99. Extra charges apply to shipments outside the continental US ($39.99-$125.00).

Where to buy Omaha Steaks?

Omaha Steaks products can be purchased online via the company’s website. Alternatively, you can order by phone or visit one of the 50+ Omaha Steaks retail stores throughout the US. A list of store locations is available on the Omaha Steaks website.

Which one is better – Omaha Steaks or Kansas City Steaks?

Omaha Steaks and Kansas City Steaks are trustworthy meat delivery services with similar offers. Read our objective Omaha Steaks vs. Kansas City Steaks comparison to find out how they differ and which service you should choose.

Where does Omaha Steaks get its meat?

Located in Nebraska, Omaha Steaks often sources locally. However, it gets its meat from farms all across the country as well. It cooperates with farms that provide naturally raised meat.

Does Omaha Steaks accept food stamps?

Omaha Steaks does not accept food stamps.

View All FAQs

User Reviews (9)

Omaha Steaks is rated 2/5, based on 9 user reviews.

The Omaha Steaks reviews listed below reflect the opinions and experiences of real users and are in no way influenced by the dating site reviewed here. Before publishing each review, our team checks whether it was submitted by an actual user in an effort to prevent false or spammy reviews.

  1. | July 19, 2020

    We receive your meats as a gift from family members. Please explain difference between “EIRIE” burgers and “EITBE” burgers.
    This gift is enjoyable.

  2. | June 6, 2020

    Just got done having lobster tails from Omaha Steak co. Along with very high price for 4 small tails the lobster was very chewy. Would not recommend at all!! However their steaks are very good and should be tried. Just stay away from those tails.

  3. | May 16, 2020

    I ordered from Omaha several years ago and the meat was terrible. If you want a decent product try Lobel’s in New York. I’ve only had their ground beef, but it was excellent. As to Omaha they ought to give the customer their money’s worth but they don’t They are all Smoke and Mirrors.

  4. | May 8, 2020

    I ordered April 17,2020 for a friends birthday and he didn’t get until May 07,202 !!!! The box has been floating around for almost a month !!! What a surprise my friend had when he opened the box to find rotten steaks !! Never again !!! If I could give them a zero I would

  5. | May 3, 2020

    We sent out son
    one of your packages recently. He lives in arizona. He called and said that he had the precooked roast and it was very good. Was a good size and could definitely feed two people. Was ready in 40 minutes. He was impressed. Just thought I’d let you know. With all the negative in the world today, just thought I’d send a positive note. Thank you, Judith torstenbo.

  6. | May 2, 2020

    I had ordered a gift package for my brother in Ark. He said it was very good so, I ordered one for myself. The filet mignon was tenderloin and it was bad. The portions were small. I called and the person on the phone tried to tell me it says tenderloin on the box but it is filet mignon. I told her it is stamped filet mignon on a tenderloin package and I know the difference as I’ve had both. I was soooooo disappointed as I was looking forward to it. I told her she could mail me a check. I will be giving my local butcher my business from now on,

  7. | April 27, 2020

    my son sends me a package every xmas. Always good quality and size. during the pandemic i ordered 2 x. Portions have gotten smaller. My order came with meatballs which were like rubber balls. bland taste. The chicken breasts were like chicken fingers. There were 4 of them and they were very thin. disappointed this time . However the burgers and kielbasi were excellent.Their seasoning is great but it should not be included in the number of items in the order. it is a small packet not a jar. Hopefully after this pandemic is over their product will go back to the same quality. I am sure it is difficult to keep up with demand now but delivery came very fast so thank you for that!

  8. | April 27, 2020

    I, personally, my family and all my friends and acquaintances, which I have sent gifts from Omaha Steaks; have been very pleased with the products. The meat, seafood, desserts and entrees are excellent. Packing and delivery too. Thanks.

  9. | April 26, 2020

    I have had very good experiences in the past with the steaks. Today I had a order arrive with 8 Butcher cut filets. The first box of 4 looked great. The second box of 4 were clearly not quality checked. There were fat rolls tucked under the bottom of 3 of the pieces.These appeared to be end cuts and there was a skin like material on the the tops and there was heavy fat streaks in the steak. I would never even buy this in a grocery store for 1/2 as much money! I have never called customer service before,but today the lady was very nice and offered me a full refund or replacement. Since I want these for Mother’s day I hope that when they come they are nicer than what I got today.

  10. | April 21, 2020

    TERRIBLE!!!! DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME AND MONEY ON THIS FALSEY ADVERTISED OVERPRICED PRODUCT!!!!!!

  11. | April 15, 2020

    I have been purchasing from Omaha Steak Co. for over 30 years and never had a problem with any of their products. I initially thought some of the prices were a bit high but I know the source of the supply. Also, since eating meats from this company I never experienced stomach problems as I had from store bought meats.

  12. | December 7, 2019

    The ads were so inviting , so I tried a gift package myself before I gifted others this holiday season.
    Good think I did. The meat was flavorless and very small portion. I get much better quality at the local butcher. One star rating is too kind.

  13. | December 3, 2019

    So I just called to place an order. I wanted to purchase 3 packages for gifts for my 3 children. I was told I could only order 2. That to me is absurd. You have missed out on a sale!

  14. | October 17, 2019

    I will never again order from them strictly on the basis that they use styrofoam. To be a mail order business, it is incredibly irresponsible to operate in this manner. Other temperature sensitive mail order businesses have stopped using this awful product.

  15. | September 25, 2019

    Hugely disappointing. I loved Omaha Steaks and did not mind paying for them- up until a year ago. We invested in half of a cow- all beef, no chicken, no potatoes, no cobbler- just meat. We got 95 pounds for about $1200 which was not unreasonable for good beef. What we got was. . . meh, at best. Ultimately the meat was comparable to that of a middling grocery chain on a bad day. Maybe what Omaha Steaks used to sell is now what is labeled “prime reserve.” Some of the burgers were pretty tasty (the brisket burgers), but very little else was worth even half of what I paid for it. Do not fall for the marketing, so-called deals or hype- just go to a butcher and support the local economy. Omaha Steaks is a marketing machine, and I am kicking myself for falling for it.

  16. | August 27, 2019

    We ordered butcher’s cut fillet mignon from Omaha Steaks as a gift. They told me the steaks were tough. At $20 each for 4 once steaks, this was pretty disappointing. Save your money, don’t buy Omaha steaks

  17. | July 30, 2019

    The burgers weren’t very good- thin, fall apart while cooking, poor taste. My wife ate all hers. I ate most and threw the rest out.

    The pork chops were pretty good, though.

    In the future I’ll buy from the local supermarket.

  18. | May 23, 2019

    While Omaha Steaks are as good as mentioned in the reviews in here, the one thing not mentioned is the return policies regarding future orders. I have ordered several times from Omaha Steaks. My orders included many different items that I was encouraged to try. Most were good. Some were not. I called to complain about the items that were not satisfactory to us and s promised, my money was refunded. What they did not tell me was that I was cut off from ordering any more from their company. They cancelled my last order and did not bother to notify me of the reason why. Their reason was because I complained about too many of their products. I found this out when I called to find out what had happened to my last order. So Omaha Steaks will continue to do business with you, as long as you do not complain about their products.

  19. | February 27, 2019

    Nearly forgot meat can taste this good. Just one complaint. Not sure how they set the prices but some cheap cuts should be cheaper and some expensive cuts that cost a fortune at the store are pretty affordable. Doesn’t make much sense, so you need to be careful not to overpay for the cheap stuff.

  20. | January 24, 2019

    About a year ago, I noticed we’ve started to eat meat less and less often, not because we don’t love it but because it’s no good. Chewy, no flavor, even with the expensive cuts. I decided to do some research and that’s how we stumbled upon Omaha Steaks. I loved that they have been around for so long so we gave them a shot. Real glad we did cause the steaks are worth every dime. Haven’t tried the meals yet but I’m guessing they’re awesome too, it’s the same meat, so maybe we’ll try them soon.

Leave a review

Your email address will not be published.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices. Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.
Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.