ButcherBox Review

UPDATED January 06. 2020.
This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close

If you are a passionate carnivore, it may sometimes seem like it is easier to find a soul mate than to get a decent cut of meat that is not filled with growth hormones and antibiotics. This modern meat lover’s plight is what inspired Mike Salguero to create ButcherBox, a top-notch meat delivery company.

Advertised as the neighborhood butcher for modern America, this service provides regular deliveries of high-quality, sustainably sourced meat and makes it easier for home cooks across the country to make healthy, protein-packed meals for their families. Read this ButcherBox review and discover all the key details about this company’s impressive offer.

ButcherBox homepage

How ButcherBox Works

ButcherBox is a subscription-based meat delivery service. It brings fresh, quality meat to your doorstep every month or every other month, depending on your family’s needs.

The company’s selection includes more than 60 meat items. You can enjoy 100% grass-fed and grass-finished beef, pasture raised and free-range organic chicken, and heritage breed pork. Both premium and convenience cuts are available.

You can choose between 2 main types of boxes – the Curated Box, including cuts handpicked by the ButcherBox team, and the Custom Box, including cuts of your choice. You can further choose between 2 box sizes. Whether you choose the Curated Box or the Custom Box, you get to decide which types of meat you want to get in your delivery.

Although a subscription is required, it comes with many perks and no limitations. As a subscriber, you get to enjoy free shipping, members-only offers, recipes, and other exciting perks. You also get to modify your subscription, switch between boxes, and pause or cancel your subscription at any point.

ButcherBox how it work

What Makes ButcherBox Different

ButcherBox has already won over more than 10,000 families across America thanks to its unique sourcing methods. The meat you get from this company is the same meat the folks at ButcherBox and their families enjoy at home. It is as good as it gets and here is how it is sourced.

ButcherBox meat is not just free from antibiotics and growth hormones. It is also humanely raised on family-run farms, with no interference with the animals’ natural diet. The animals on these farms have full access to both pastures and shelters and they are not kept in crowded spaces. They spend their lives out in the open, interacting with other animals.

The reason why not all animals are grown this way is that it is expensive. According to expert estimates, less than 5% of the beef currently on the market is grass-fed, making this kind of high-quality meat hard to find. With ButcherBox, you do not only get the highest-quality meat delivered to your doorstep but also support hardworking local farmers who employ humane raising practices.

ButcherBox Products

As mentioned earlier in this ButcherBox review, there are more than 60 delicious meat items to choose from and you can decide whether you want to handpick the items yourself or get a tasty surprise in your box. Now, we will provide more details about what is inside ButcherBox boxes.

ButcherBox Meals And Recipes

Curated Box

With the Curated Box, you get a nice mix of premium and convenience cuts selected by the ButcherBox team. You can expect to get both New York strip, ribeye, and other fancy steaks and easy-to-cook chicken thighs, sirloin steaks, and roasts. Depending on your preferences, you can decide whether you want to receive a mixed box including beef, pork, and chicken, a beef and pork box, a beef and chicken box or a beef-only box.

You can choose between the smaller Classic box and the larger Big box. The Classic box brings you 8-11 lbs. of meat, enough to make around 24 meals, while the Big box contains 16-22 lbs. of meat, allowing you to cook around 48 tasty meals.

If you wish, you can customize your box by adding any of the 12 add-ons available, including burgers, breakfast sausage, ground beef, boneless pork chops, boneless, skinless chicken thighs, uncured, sugar-free bacon, and more.

Custom Box

The Custom Box includes up to 21 items of your choice. Just like with the Curated box, you can choose between two box sizes and include any of the 12 add-ons. With the Custom Box, the Classic size brings you 9-14 lbs. of meat, good for around 30 meals, and the Big box comes with 18-26 lbs. of meat, which should be enough to cook around 60 individual meals.

In addition to the gorgeous meat, ButcherBox provides lovely, inspiring recipes that make perfect use of the items in your box. The prep time usually ranges from just 5 to around 30 minutes. There are dozens upon dozens of recipes in the ButcherBox recipe library, so you can easily find something you would like to try out.

ButcherBox Meal custom box

Pricing

With ButcherBox, pricing is perfectly straightforward, so you always know exactly how much your box is going to cost. The price exclusively depends on the box type and box size you choose.

With the Curated Box, the price of the Classic-sized box is $129 per month. The Big box costs $238 per month. If you opt for the Custom box, you get the Classic-sized box for $149 per month and the Big box for $270 per month.

Of course, you can always throw in a couple of add-ons when you need some extra meat. The prices of add-ons range between $7 and $25 per pack, depending on whether you opt for premium or convenience cuts. Shipping is always free and there are no additional or hidden costs.

ButcherBox pricing

Delivery Areas

At the moment, ButcherBox delivery map covers the entire contiguous US. The company is actively working on finding adequate delivery solutions that would allow it to ship its products to Alaska, Hawaii, and Canada. The boxes are shipped from Monday to Friday and deliveries are made from Tuesday to Saturday. Deliveries can be made to both home and business addresses. However, the company does not recommend using a business address due to potential issues caused by limited business hours.

ButcherBox Pros And Cons

To make sure ButcherBox meets all your standards and expectations, it is important to know its biggest advantages and disadvantages. With a short overview of its pros and cons, you can easily decide if ButcherBox is the right company for you.

Pros
  • More than 60 high-quality meat items
  • 100% grass-fed beef, organic chicken, and heritage breed pork
  • Great selection of both premium and convenience cuts
  • Customizable boxes
  • Delicious add-ons
  • Excellent membership perks
  • Mouthwatering recipes
  • Flexible subscription
  • Free shipping

Cons

  • Not too affordable

Bottom Line

ButcherBox promises to bring the best natural meat straight to your doorstep and from our experience, the quality really is as high as advertised. The meat is more flavorful and boasts a richer texture than the kind you get at the store. What is great is that you can decide exactly what you want to get in your box and there are tons of options to choose from.

The boxes may be a bit too large for families that do not eat meat every day, but since you can receive the boxes every other month, this should not be too big of a problem. We have to admit that the prices are not as low as we would like them to be. However, the truth is that in order to raise animals the natural way, farmers need to invest a lot of money, so keeping that in mind, the prices are more than reasonable. Not only that, but after tasting the meat, we can say that it is definitely worth it.


User Reviews (46)

ButcherBox customer rating based on 46 user reviews.

The ButcherBox reviews listed below reflect the opinions and experiences of real users and are in no way influenced by the dating site reviewed here. Before publishing each review, our team checks whether it was submitted by an actual user in an effort to prevent false or spammy reviews.

  1. Tom | August 29, 2019

    Be careful prior to ordering. I was trying this service based on the 2 LB of ground beef for life. It wasn’t until after the order had processed that there was any indication that the promotion was not part of my order. Even then, I only found out by making a call to customer service. Additionally, though the product is advertised as “less than $6.00 per meal”, it actually comes out to anywhere between $12.00 and $17.00 per pound of meat. Very expensive. Needless to say, I have buyers remorse and cancelled the day after I first subscribed. (Of course, though I subscribed at 3:30 in the afternoon, the order “…has gone to shipping” by 7:30 the next day, forcing me to accept the order — I wonder if they would have shipped a refund as quickly?

  2. Tony | August 23, 2019

    Torn packaging – AGAIN. I signed up recently with the promo for Free Burgers for Summer. The first delivery came, the tops of each 4-pack of burgers were torn, and the top burger of each package was clearly freezer-burnt, so I decided not to trust the other burgers in the packages. I emailed customer service, sent pictures, got some non-related info about how their meat packaging may contain wrinkles or some nonsense, but they agreed to double the burgers in the following month’s delivery. Received that delivery yesterday – two of the four 4-packs of burgers have torn packaging on top!

    Last month I did cook and eat everything I received (except the burgers), although I was very uneasy trusting the condition of the meat in all the other packages.

    Today I cancelled my subscription, and am going to request a refund for the entire box, as I don’t want to eat any more meat from this company.

  3. greg curran | August 8, 2019

    While pricier than our local butcher, the meat is so much tastier. I can’t recall any other meat tasting as flavorful, fresh and delicious! Our only negative experience was with the St. Louis ribs, and after sending an email saying that we were disappointed, we were promptly given a credit for the ribs. I have never had any of the negative issues I see in some of the other reviews and I have recommended Butcher Box to friends and family…

  4. Francois | August 2, 2019

    Butcher Box cheated me with a special that was to weigh 48oz (3lbs) but actually weighted 38.2 oz, that’s 21% less . I hate companies that that are dishonest and ripp their customers.
    Can’t trust= zero star.

  5. Lynda Holland | July 5, 2019

    I agree that is a bit pricey, but it actually saves us money because we dont have to go to a grocery store, where we surely would buy $60.00 worth of things we really don’t need. The quality is excellent. The meat is always delicious. I too have had open or punctured packs of meat. They gladly refunded my money, and assured me that they are working on the problem. Customer service has been five star. I call at random times, and always get great results.

  6. Lara Schepp | June 23, 2019

    We have been ButcherBox customers for over 2 years and overall love them. The meat is top quality and the price is tolerable based on what you are getting. It is grass fed, grass finished beef, so you are going to pay more than what you would for the disgusting mass produced, GMO fed meat that you would get at Walmart or other major grocery store chains. For my family’s health, it is worth the price. We get the classic sized, custom box and it works for a family of 4, but we also don’t eat a ton of meat. I like the custom box because you can pick the meats you want. We usually get a reminder about a week before our box ships, but I just program a reminder into my iPhone in case I want to make changes to my shipment. We have had a couple of instances where customer service was lacking, but we’ve also had times when it was exceptional. The positives far outweigh any negatives. You should give it a try and see if it works for you.

More user reviews

Leave a review

Your email address will not be published.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices. Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.
Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.