ButcherBox VS Crowd Cow Comparison

UPDATED Oct. 2019
Table Of Contents+
This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close

If you are struggling to decide between ButcherBox and Crowd Cow, you have come to the right place. For your convenience, we have gathered all the important facts about these 2 meat deliveries and laid them out in our side-by-side ButcherBox VS Crowd Cow comparison. Discover how the services measure up to one another in terms of everything from meat quality and variety to sourcing practices and ordering flexibility and easily decide which one is better for you.

Crowd Cow
Optimally fresh meat of superior quality
VS
ButcherBox
Meat The Way Nature Intended It To Be

Highlights

Crowd Cow
Crowd Cow sells one cow at a time, ensuring optimal freshness and flavor. Order as much meat as you wish, whenever you want, or subscribe to get regular deliveries of pasture-raised ground beef.
  • Price Range: $$
  • Average Price Per Meal: $16.00
  • Shipping Cost: $12.99
  • Delivery Area: 48 states
ButcherBox
ButcherBox offers monthly deliveries of pasture-raised, grass-fed beef and high-quality, natural pork and chicken. Opt for a subscription and handpick the items in your box or let the experts do the choosing. Enjoy tasty meat gifts and free shipping with all orders.
  • Price Range: $
  • Average Price Per Meal: $149.00
  • Shipping Cost: $0
  • Delivery Area: 50 states

Compare Features

Crowd Cow
Best For
Best for meat lovers who want to know exactly where their meat comes from
Meat Selection
Crowd Cow has limited its selection to high-quality beef, pork, and chicken. It offers over 100 different cuts at all times, ranging from New York strip steak to cow tongue and chicken feet and liver.
Meat Quality
Crowd Cow brings you 100% grass-fed beef, pasture-raised, grain-fed beef, Japanese A5 Wagyu beef, pasture-raised heritage pork, and pasture-raised chicken.
Other Products
Crowd Cow only sells meat.
Sourcing Practices
Crowd Cow obtains meat from family-owned farms and ranches across the country, which are carefully vetted to ensure they employ the best sustainability practices. The company provides plenty of details on each of its partner farms and ranches, so you can make an informed purchasing decision.
Flexibility
With Crowd Cow, you can opt for one-off orders with no minimum value or subscribe. The company offers flexible subscriptions, allowing you to speed up or postpone your delivery and cancel your subscription at any time.
Refunds
If you are not satisfied with your shipment, get in touch with Crowd Cow's customer support staff within 7 days. You may receive a replacement or a full or partial refund, depending on the circumstances.
Shipping Costs
Crowd Cow charges $12.99+ for shipping. The costs vary depending on location.
Delivery Area
Crowd Cow ships all over the continental US.
ButcherBox
Best For
Best for carnivorous families that want to eat healthily
Meat Selection
ButcherBox offers more than 60 different cuts of beef, pork, and chicken, available in curated and custom boxes. You can purchase delicious cuts like New York strip steak, ribeye, sirloin steaks, roasts, chops or ribs and various interesting add-ons such as breakfast sausage, burgers, and uncured, sugar-free bacon.
Meat Quality
ButcherBox offers premium-quality meat. Its beef is grass-fed and grass-finished, it only sells heritage pork, and its chicken is free-range and organic.
Other Products
ButcherBox only sells meat.
Sourcing Practices
The meat you receive from ButcherBox is grown on family-owned farms that employ humane cattle-raising practices. The animals interact with one another in the pastures, they have safe, uncrowded shelters, and the farmers do not interfere with their natural diet.
Flexibility
ButcherBox offers flexible subscriptions that you can modify, pause or cancel at any time. Keep in mind that you should make the desired changes before your order is billed.
Refunds
If something is wrong with your shipment, reach out to ButcherBox immediately and you can get a replacement or a refund.
Shipping Costs
ButcherBox offers free shipping on all orders.
Delivery Area
ButcherBox ships throughout the contiguous US.

Meat Types

Crowd Cow
Beef
Pork
Lamb
Chicken
Turkey
Duck
Quail
Elk
Venison
Bison
Rabbit
Charcuterie
Organs
Bones
Fat
ButcherBox
Beef
Pork
Lamb
Chicken
Turkey
Duck
Quail
Elk
Venison
Bison
Rabbit
Charcuterie
Organs
Bones
Fat

Compare Ratings

Crowd Cow
FINAL RATING
8.5/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price
ButcherBox
FINAL RATING
9.0/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price

Compare Customer Reviews

Crowd Cow
  • Submitted By Zachary A. on 08/03/2019
    My first order was delayed by one day, and as a result was thrown in the trash by the delivery service. Will not use the service again.
  • Submitted By Deonne on 06/25/2019
    I ordered the Pasture Raised Grain Finished Black Angus Ribeye From Wolfe Brothers Farm. I found a good deal for 2 Ribeyes. Loved the packaging and the beef was frozen. It took some time to order because I have never ordered beef online but everything looked fresh and delicious.I have to be honest to say the beef looked great and I notice some beef have a smell once you take it out the packaging but I smelled nothing but freshness. The beef wasn’t tender and I wasn’t impressed at all. CC tried to make it right but I see no need to continue to order beef from them.I really wanted to try the Wagyu but never mind. I actually found a local farm in the area called Hancock Family Farms I will buy my fresh beef from and he wants honest opinions and stands by his product. I don’t like a business not standing by their product, customer service told me they have like 70 farms so I should find something I like. I’m really supposed to try all farms to just get a piece of tender beef, no thanks CC.
  • Submitted By Richard Smith on 02/07/2019
    Really good but too expensive.
  • Submitted By Larry Young on 01/08/2019
    Great idea and even greater product. My father was a rancher and I know how hard it can be, services like these are much-needed, not only because it’s so hard to get healthy meat but because they actually help ranchers, which is a big plus in my book.
ButcherBox
  • Submitted By Tom on 08/29/2019
    Be careful prior to ordering. I was trying this service based on the 2 LB of ground beef for life. It wasn't until after the order had processed that there was any indication that the promotion was not part of my order. Even then, I only found out by making a call to customer service. Additionally, though the product is advertised as "less than $6.00 per meal", it actually comes out to anywhere between $12.00 and $17.00 per pound of meat. Very expensive. Needless to say, I have buyers remorse and cancelled the day after I first subscribed. (Of course, though I subscribed at 3:30 in the afternoon, the order "...has gone to shipping" by 7:30 the next day, forcing me to accept the order -- I wonder if they would have shipped a refund as quickly?
  • Submitted By Tony on 08/23/2019
    Torn packaging - AGAIN. I signed up recently with the promo for Free Burgers for Summer. The first delivery came, the tops of each 4-pack of burgers were torn, and the top burger of each package was clearly freezer-burnt, so I decided not to trust the other burgers in the packages. I emailed customer service, sent pictures, got some non-related info about how their meat packaging may contain wrinkles or some nonsense, but they agreed to double the burgers in the following month's delivery. Received that delivery yesterday - two of the four 4-packs of burgers have torn packaging on top!Last month I did cook and eat everything I received (except the burgers), although I was very uneasy trusting the condition of the meat in all the other packages.Today I cancelled my subscription, and am going to request a refund for the entire box, as I don't want to eat any more meat from this company.
  • Submitted By greg curran on 08/08/2019
    While pricier than our local butcher, the meat is so much tastier. I can't recall any other meat tasting as flavorful, fresh and delicious! Our only negative experience was with the St. Louis ribs, and after sending an email saying that we were disappointed, we were promptly given a credit for the ribs. I have never had any of the negative issues I see in some of the other reviews and I have recommended Butcher Box to friends and family...
  • Submitted By Francois on 08/02/2019
    Butcher Box cheated me with a special that was to weigh 48oz (3lbs) but actually weighted 38.2 oz, that's 21% less . I hate companies that that are dishonest and ripp their customers. Can't trust= zero star.

Winner

ButcherBox is one of the easiest ways to enjoy the highest-quality, grass-fed beef, organic chicken, and heritage breed pork. The service offers an impressive range of antibiotic-free, hormone-free premium and convenience cuts and allows you to decide on both the quantity and selection of meat in your box. Read more about it in our ButcherBox review.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices. Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.
Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.