ButcherBox VS Chicago Steak Company

UPDATED Apr. 2019
Table Of Contents+
This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close

Chicago Steak Company and ButcherBox are designed to take the stress out of meal planning and this Chicago Steak Company VS ButcherBox comparison is designed to make it much easier to choose between them. Get a comprehensive overview of these companies’ crucial features and scroll down to discover the definite winner of the comparison.

Chicago Steak Company
The Best Steaks Money Can Buy
VS
ButcherBox
Meat The Way Nature Intended It To Be

Highlights

Chicago Steak Company
If you want to enjoy the best steaks in all of America (the top 2%), Chicago Steak Company is the right choice for you. Served in 5-star restaurants and steakhouses, its steaks are of the highest quality, just like its heritage pork and all-natural chicken. Order subscription-free or join a steak club.
  • Shipping Cost: $19.99 *
  • Delivery Area: 50 states
*Shipping is free with subscriptions, but the same is not true for one-time orders
ButcherBox
ButcherBox offers monthly deliveries of pasture-raised, grass-fed beef and high-quality, natural pork and chicken. Opt for a subscription and handpick the items in your box or let the experts do the choosing. Enjoy tasty meat gifts and free shipping with all orders.
  • Shipping Cost: $0
  • Delivery Area: 50 states

Compare Features

Chicago Steak Company
Best For
Best for steak lovers with a sophisticated palate
Meat Selection
As its name suggests, Chicago Steak Company primarily focuses on USDA Choice and USDA Prime beefsteaks. Its offer also includes pork and chicken. You can opt for Angus beef, dry-aged and wet-aged steaks, American Wagyu, pork chops, roasts, ribs, ham, marinated chicken breasts, and other gourmet delights.
Meat Quality
Chicago Steak Company offers the highest-grade beef, hand-selected and hand-cut, as well as premium Kurobuta pork and free-range turkey and chicken.
Other Products
Extras available in the Chicago Steak Company online shop include fresh fish and seafood, decadent desserts, and assortments of gourmet treats.
Sourcing Practices
Chicago Steak Company only sources Midwest-raised heritage cattle, sustainably grown and completely natural, adhering to the highest quality standards. Its seafood is freshly caught by local fishermen.
Flexibility
Chicago Steak Company lets you choose between one-off orders and subscriptions. There is no minimum value for one-off orders. The subscriptions are designed as gift clubs. If you subscribe, you agree to receive recurring shipments for 6 or 12 months.
Refunds
Chicago Steak Company offers a satisfaction guarantee. If there is something wrong with your shipment, you can request a refund, but keep in mind that authorized returns may be required.
Shipping Costs
Chicago Steak Company only offers free shipping with subscriptions. With one-off orders, shipping costs amount to $19.99 - $59.99, depending on order value, desired shipping method, and location.
Delivery Area
Chicago Steak Company ships to all 50 US states.
ButcherBox
Best For
Best for carnivorous families that want to eat healthily
Meat Selection
ButcherBox offers more than 60 different cuts of beef, pork, and chicken, available in curated and custom boxes. You can purchase delicious cuts like New York strip steak, ribeye, sirloin steaks, roasts, chops or ribs and various interesting add-ons such as breakfast sausage, burgers, and uncured, sugar-free bacon.
Meat Quality
ButcherBox offers premium-quality meat. Its beef is grass-fed and grass-finished, it only sells heritage pork, and its chicken is free-range and organic.
Other Products
ButcherBox only sells meat.
Sourcing Practices
The meat you receive from ButcherBox is grown on family-owned farms that employ humane cattle-raising practices. The animals interact with one another in the pastures, they have safe, uncrowded shelters, and the farmers do not interfere with their natural diet.
Flexibility
ButcherBox offers flexible subscriptions that you can modify, pause or cancel at any time. Keep in mind that you should make the desired changes before your order is billed.
Refunds
If something is wrong with your shipment, reach out to ButcherBox immediately and you can get a replacement or a refund.
Shipping Costs
ButcherBox offers free shipping on all orders.
Delivery Area
ButcherBox ships throughout the contiguous US.

Meat Types

Chicago Steak Company
Beef
Pork
Lamb
Chicken
Turkey
Duck
Quail
Elk
Venison
Bison
Rabbit
Charcuterie
Organs
Bones
Fat
ButcherBox
Beef
Pork
Lamb
Chicken
Turkey
Duck
Quail
Elk
Venison
Bison
Rabbit
Charcuterie
Organs
Bones
Fat

Compare Ratings

Chicago Steak Company
FINAL RATING
8.9/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price
ButcherBox
FINAL RATING
9.0/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price

Compare Customer Reviews

Chicago Steak Company
  • Submitted By Bob Adams on 06/29/2018
    The. best. steaks. ever. Nothing to add, it's what I dream about when I'm eating veg.
  • Submitted By Josh Summers on 04/22/2018
    I'm not filthy rich so I only shop at CSC a couple of times a year. They sure work hard to make everything perfect, but the prices are too high. It's not that I'm cheap, I'm just not made of money, so I just treat myself to a couple of steaks every once in a while, because they really are good.
ButcherBox
  • Submitted By Becky on 03/28/2019
    These people have the worst customer service. I have had several issues with boxes being shipped with no chance to bump the order. One customer service rep told me it is not their policy to send reminder emails, even though I have received one before most orders. Then a manager tells me that, yes, they do. I didn't receive the email for the latest box until 3:00 this morning and then another enail at 10:30 that it shipped. No chance to bump it. And salmon was added to it, that I did not authorize. Now I have to pay for $200+ pounds of meat that I would have bumped had I received the warning email. The manager did not even try to make it right. She threatened to hang up on me as she said the call was no longer productive when I tried to argue with her. She didn't even offer a discount or anything. I will be canceling my account and taking this up with my credit card company and the BBB.
  • Submitted By Ceci on 03/15/2019
    Terrible, I would give it ZERO stars if I could. Deceiving, scamming, all around a big LIE! It says on their website you would get 8-11 lbs of beef (enough for about 24 meals). I got a total of 7 lbs including 2 lbs of ground beef (which we all know it is available and cheap anywhere). I did the math and you are paying over $20 a lb for this beef which is ridiculous even for grass fed... Besides, the lie is what really annoys me the most. I tried to talk to their Customer Service chat but the person answering was really dumb and didn't even acknowledge the issue properly so I cancelled after the first delivery...
  • Submitted By Marty Oman on 03/05/2019
    Wasn’t sure it was worth the cash, because I usually pay much less for decent quality meat. My wife really wanted to order, because her best friend said they were the best and I’m not sorry we decided to subscribe in the end. Much better than what we usually get, got the mixed box, just enough for the 2 of us, really satisfied with the first shipment, we’ll see if they keep up the good work.
  • Submitted By Tim Chaffin on 02/24/2019
    First of all, great meat and it arrived in perfect shape. I let them choose what goes into the box and I was pleasantly surprised to see that they were mostly premium cuts. I didn’t give them 5 stars because it really doesn’t make sense to allow for such huge variations in quantity, like someone already pointed out. It’s not really cheap, so it would be more fair if they said exactly how much meat you get, so you can figure out if the prices is ok or not.

Winner

ButcherBox is one of the easiest ways to enjoy the highest-quality, grass-fed beef, organic chicken, and heritage breed pork. The service offers an impressive range of antibiotic-free, hormone-free premium and convenience cuts and allows you to decide on both the quantity and selection of meat in your box. Read more about it in our ButcherBox review.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices. Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.
Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.