Foodstirs Review

UPDATED July 15. 2024.
This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close

If you love baking but rarely have enough time for a proper baking session, Foodstirs can help speed up the process so you can bake as often as you wish, even when on a tight schedule. If you would love to bake but are afraid that the results would not be as impressive as you would want them to be, once again, Foodstirs can save the day and help you successfully start a loving friendship with your rolling pin and oven. If this does not sound good enough, maybe it is worth noting that Foodstirs is the brainchild of Galit Laibow, Greg Fleishman, and none other than Sarah Michelle Gellar.

Therefore, if you want to discover the wonders of dough on your own or share the joy with your little ones and bake something healthy, delicious, and beautiful, keep reading this Foodstirs review and find out how easy baking can be with this interesting delivery service.

Foodstirs Review home page

How Foodstirs Works

With Foodstirs, you can shop commitment-free and handpick the lovely items from its shop. You can choose from a variety of baking mixes, baking kits, and even cool sweatshirts, t-shirts, and tote bags. If you want to subscribe, you can become a member of its Baker’s Club and receive regular deliveries of baking kits shipped out every other month.

All bi-monthly subscription boxes feature different holiday-inspired and season-inspired themes. They include baking mixes, decorations, shapes and supplies, and simple 6-step recipes with clear instructions that even the most inexperienced bakers can follow.

You can decide on the length of your subscription and choose to receive between 1 and 12 kits. At the end of the subscription period, your subscription is automatically renewed and reset to the 1-kit subscription plan. If you want to end your subscription, you can get in touch with Foodstirs’ customer support via phone and have your account deactivated. Be sure to state your intention to cancel by the last day of the month in order to avoid being charged for the next shipment.

How Foodstirs Works

What Makes Foodstirs Different

It is not every day that we stumble upon a delivery service that exclusively focuses on baking. However, that is not the only distinctive feature of this service. Namely, it is the quality of its baking mixes and kits that truly sets it apart. Its products are organic and ethically sourced and everything from mixes and decorations is healthy, natural, and suitable for different diets. Everyone over the age of 6 can enjoy whipping up a wonder with Foodstirs baking kits.

Apart from focusing on organic ingredients, the service goes an extra mile to ensure its mixes and kits are perfectly good for you. Namely, it is currently the only quick-scratch baking brand that uses biodynamic sugar in its mixes. Biodynamic sugar is not refined and it is made of organic cane juice that is harvested, evaporated, and crystalized, all within a single day. It is commonly referred to as the most sustainable sugar currently available.

If you want to get a special gift for a fellow baker, you have plenty of options to choose from. You can opt for a gift subscription, a $25, $50 or $100 gift card, Sarah Michelle Gellar’s cookbook or some nice wearable swag with funny and sweet baking-related print.

If you choose to join the company’s referral program, both you and your friends can get great discounts. Everyone who joins Foodstirs using your referral link gets 25% off any subscription and you get 25% off for every successful referral.

Meals And Recipes

Foodstirs meal options
For Kids
For Singles

In the previous sections of this Foodstirs review, we mentioned that this company focuses on providing healthy, certified organic, non-GMO baking kits and mixes. All products are certified kosher, vegetarian-friendly, and nut-free. The Organic Vanilla Frosting Mix is gluten-free as well.

Foodstirs Recipes

The recipes do call for eggs and milk, but all of the products are vegan-friendly, except for the Organic Sunday Stacks Pancake Mix, and eggs and milk can be substituted with flaxseed and almond and coconut milk. Customers who are vegans can reach out to the support staff and get great recommendations for adequate substitutions for non-vegan ingredients included in the recipes.

In the Foodstirs shop, you can find 7 different baking kits and around a dozen of baking mixes that can be purchased individually or in 3-packs. Both the kits available in the shop and the ones you receive with the subscription include organic baking mixes, plant-based food dyes, and lovely decorations and baking supplies, including sprinkles, cupcake liners, lollypop sticks for cake pops, molds, cookie cutters, and more.

Foodstirs meals

The recipes are wonderfully easy to follow and kid-friendly, with precise instructions that guide you through the entire baking process. Apart from what is included in your kit, you just need perishable goods such as eggs and milk and standard kitchen materials. Foodstirs products have a long shelf life and can sit in your pantry for up to 12 months.


If you choose to join the Baker’s Club, you can opt for the 1-kit, 3-kit, 6-kit or 12-kit subscription. With the 1-kit subscription, you pay $18.99 per kit, the 3-kit subscription costs $18.34 per kit, the price of the 6-kit subscription is 16.84 per kit, and the 12-kit subscription costs $15.26 per kit. All subscriptions come with shipping included, except for the 1-kit subscription.

Foodstirs price

Now, let us take a look at the prices of individual items available at the store. Baking mixes normally cost $5.99 per pack or $17.99 per 3-pack. Baking kits cost $18.99 each. When it comes to wearable swag, sweatshirts cost $25, t-shirts cost $15, and tote bags cost $20. You can get Sarah Michelle Gellar’s cookbook Stirring Up Fun With Food for $16.95.

As we mentioned previously, shipping is included in longer subscriptions but it is not free for all orders. The cost of shipping depends on your location.

Delivery Areas

Foodstirs ships its goods all over the US. At the moment, it does not offer international shipping. The goods are shipped via USPS and the standard shipping time is 5 to 7 business days. Subscription kits are shipped on the 10th of every even-numbered month. The company does not accept returns.

Foodstirs products can also be found in large stores such as Whole Foods and Kroger. It is possible to make a purchase via Instacart as well.

Foodstirs Pros And Cons

To make sure Foodstirs meets all your standards and expectations, it is important to know its biggest advantages and disadvantages. With a short overview of its pros and cons, you can easily decide if Foodstirs is the right meal kit service for you.

  • Subscribe or shop at your leisure
  • A lovely selection of healthy baking mixes and kits
  • Certified organic, non-GMO, and kosher
  • Vegan-friendly and nut-free
  • 12-month shelf life
  • Great gifts for home bakers
  • The only quick-scratch baking brand using unrefined, biodynamic sugar


  • Shipping is not free on all orders
  • Only one gluten-free item

Sample Dishes

If you subscribe to Foodstirs, you can easily prepare culinary masterpieces using only the ingredients and recipes found in your meal kit box. You may not be a pro chef just yet, but with Foodstirs, you can easily make restaurant-grade meals. You don’t have to take our word for it – check out the images below to get a better idea of the types of dishes you can enjoy with Foodstirs.

Bottom Line

Foodstirs is an enchanting service created and run by parents who know that baking is one of the best activities for bonding and having fun with the little ones. The lovely recipes and baking kits and mixes it offers can help both adults and kids learn how to bake without getting discouraged by complex or unclear instructions or failed attempts at a cake pop. With Foodstirs, you can get perfect results every time. Plus, the products are incredibly healthy, certified organic and kosher, and suitable for various diets, so virtually everyone can enjoy them. Finally, the prices are quite affordable, so there is nothing preventing you from enjoying an utterly satisfying baking experience with delicious results.

Foodstirs FAQ

Where can I buy Foodstirs products?

You can buy Foodstirs products via the Foodstirs website. You can order with or without a subscription. The company’s products are also available at select retailers, such as Target, Whole Foods, and Kroger.

How do I cancel my Foodstirs subscription?

You can cancel your Foodstirs subscription by reaching out to the company’s customer support staff via phone or email.

Who owns Foodstirs?

Foodstirs is a private company owned by Sarah Michelle Gellar, Galit Laibow, and Greg Fleishman.

View All FAQs

User Reviews (5)

Foodstirs is rated 3/5, based on 5 user reviews.

The Foodstirs reviews listed below reflect the opinions and experiences of real users and are in no way influenced by the service reviewed here. Before publishing each review, our team checks whether it was submitted by an actual user in an effort to prevent false or spammy reviews.

  1. | October 18, 2021

    I have purchased a subscription for my granddaughters for years. They love cooking together. At the end of each subscription I ask them if they want it continued. The answer is “Yes”, however, ….”as long as new kits are sent and there are no repeats.” When this has happened I call and Foodstirs makes the correction. They love it… now 12 and 14. Never too old to cook.

  2. | March 18, 2020

    This is the second time I have been disappointed with Foodstirs. I orders 2, 3 month subscriptions for 2 of my granddaughters. There customer service is horrible. I tried to contact them when I had a problem with the first delivery. No one answers their phone and no one will return messages. I wrote an e-mail because they shorted us on an items needed for both our December order and the February order as well. I not received a response. I do not recommend this company for their bad customer service and lack of accurate orders.

  3. | February 6, 2019

    I purchased the organic brooklyn salted chocolate chip with sea salt brownie mix and it turned out terrible, how on earth can a brownie come out so wrong , hard as a rock on the outside so when i went to slice it it almost broke my knife, it was extremely hard the inside was fine but its all over the place and i was going to serve this to company tomorrow and it looks like i will have to make something else. very disappointing

  4. | December 22, 2017

    We loved every kit we ordered, particularly out of this world donuts. It is easier that I thought, the decorations are beautiful and I love that it’s organic.

  5. | October 29, 2017

    I’m not much of a baker and I thought that I could never make the treats look as good as the ones in the photos, but I was pleasantly surprised to see that it is not that hard at all. I served the cake pops and pop-corn cupcakes at a party last week, everyone loved them!

  6. | October 14, 2017

    The kits could be a bit cheaper, but you do get the molds and stuff that you get to keep, so I guess it’s ok.

Leave a review

Your email address will not be published.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices. Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.
Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.