Plated VS HelloFresh

UPDATED Jun. 2018
Table Of Contents+

Plated and HelloFresh are both on our list of the top meal delivery services currently on the market and the best way to gauge their unique advantages and potential flaws is to measure them directly against each other, one feature at a time.

In order to provide you with a full parallel overview, we created this comprehensive Plated vs. HelloFresh comparison where we investigate and compare the most important features you need to keep in mind when determining whether Plated or HelloFresh is a better fit for your personal needs and expectations.

Plated
Cooking with superior ingredients
VS
HelloFresh
Fresh, tasty and healthy cooking

Highlights

Plated
Plated offers incredible ordering flexibility, competitive pricing, and one of the richest menus in the meal kit market, with recipes for a vast range of tastes, diets, and cooking skill levels.
  • Average Price Per Meal: $9.95
  • Shipping Cost: $0 *
  • Delivery Area: 48 states
*except on weekly plans under $60
HelloFresh
HelloFresh is an allergen-friendly, vegetarian-friendly, flexible, and quite affordable meal kit delivery, allowing you to cook meals that suit your taste in little time, hassle-free, while staying on budget.
  • Average Price Per Meal: $9.99
  • Shipping Cost: $0
  • Delivery Area: 48 states

Compare Features

Plated
Best For
Best for semi-experienced home cooks who value variety and want to eat healthily
Menu/Meal Plans
Plated features one menu that changes on a weekly basis.
Recipes/Meal Options
Plated offers 20 new recipes each week, plus 2 desserts.
Meal & Recipe Variety
Every week, the Plated menu features fresh meal ideas suitable for omnivore, vegetarian, gluten-free, low-calorie, and low-carb diets. The recipes are inspired by popular world cuisines, such as French, Italian, Indian, Mexican, Chinese, and traditional American cuisine. Most items are quick-prep recipes with hands-on time ranging from 10 to 30 minutes.
Food Quality
Plated does not only offer sustainably sourced meat & seafood and the freshest seasonal produce from the best local farms but also supplies home cooks with rare artisanal spices that give rich flavor and tantalizing aroma to every dish.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
Plated carefully calculates its portion sizes to satisfy the needs of an average adult, with no leftovers. By thoughtfully combining high-quality ingredients into satisfying meals, the Plated culinary team ensures all meals are rich in nutrients and well-balanced, with plenty of items under 600 calories.
Subscription Flexibility
With Plated, you can change your box's recipes or servings at any time. You can also skip, pause or cancel your order whenever you want. Keep in mind that all changes to your subscription must be made by noon six days before your delivery is due.
Refunds
If you are not satisfied with your delivery or something is missing from your box, you can contact Plated and they may issue a credit to your account.
HelloFresh
Best For
Best for busy home cooks seeking healthier versions of comforting classics
Menu/Meal Plans
With HelloFresh, you can opt for the Veggie Plan, Classic Plan or Family Plan.
Recipes/Meal Options
HelloFresh offers 8 new recipes on the Classic Menu, 3 new recipes on the Veggie Menu, and 5 new recipes on the Family Menu each week.
Meal & Recipe Variety
HelloFresh converts all-time favorites into more colorful, quick-to-make meals that can be ready to eat in as little as 20 minutes. Its selection includes omnivore, vegetarian, kid-friendly, egg-free, nut-free, gluten-free, and dairy-free recipes. Most meals are designed for everyday home dining, with occasional premium dishes for special occasions.
Food Quality
HelloFresh provides locally sourced ingredients of the highest quality. Its seafood is ocean-friendly, wild-caught, and recommended by the Seafood Watch. Its meat originates from local farms that meet the highest standards of quality. Its produce is natural, freshly picked, and comes from family-owned farms.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
The meals you cook with HelloFresh are made of nutrient-packed ingredients and have optimal nutritional value. Portions are ample enough to keep you full but do not count on leftovers.
Subscription Flexibility
With HelloFresh, you can modify your subscription or switch between plans anytime. You can also pause, skip or cancel your order whenever you wish. All changes to your subscription must be made by 11:59 pm PST 5 days prior to your next scheduled delivery
Refunds
HelloFresh offers refunds if you are not satisfied with your delivery. Refunds can take 3-5 days to process.

Compare Plans & Pricing

Plated
Plated Plans & Pricing
2 Servings
Meals per weekMeal kit pricePrice per serving
2$47.80 (first week: $35.85)$11.95
3$71.70 (first week: $53.77)$11.95
4$95.60 (first week: $71.70)$11.95
3 servings
Meals per weekMeal kit pricePrice per serving
2$59.70 (first week: $44.77)$9.95
3$89.55 (first week: $67.16)$9.95
4$119.40 (first week: $89.55)$9.95
4 servings
Meals per weekMeal kit pricePrice per serving
2$79.60 (first week: $59.70)$9.95
3$119.40 (first week: $89.55)$9.95
4$159.20 (first week: $119.40)$9.95
HelloFresh
HelloFresh Plans & Pricing
Veggie Plan (2 servings)
Meals per weekMeal kit pricePrice per serving
3$59.94$9.99
Veggie Plan (4 servings)
Meals per weekMeal kit pricePrice per serving
3$119.98$9.99
Classic Plan (2 servings)
Meals per weekMeal kit pricePrice per serving
2$39.96$9.99
3$59.94$9.99
4$79.92$9.99
Classic Plan (4 servings)
Meals per weekMeal kit pricePrice per serving
3$119.88$9.99
Family Plan (4 servings)
Meals per weekMeal kit pricePrice per serving
2$69.92$8.74
3$104.88$8.74

Suitable For

Plated
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One
HelloFresh
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One

Compare Meal Options

Plated
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals
HelloFresh
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals

Compare Sample Meals

Plated
HelloFresh

Compare Extras

Plated
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace
HelloFresh
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace

Compare Ratings

Plated
FINAL RATING
9.6/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price
HelloFresh
FINAL RATING
9.5/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price

Compare User Reviews

Plated
  • Submitted By Laura on 06/16/2018
    The convenience of this service is a 4*, but, we received meal kits with spoiled ingredients on our first delivery in 2/3 recipes. There were missing ingredients, too. It's hard to make za'atar French fries without the spice--it's not something in my spice collection.The second week, we were promised delivery on Friday. The food was shipped on Wednesday, and wasn't delivered until Saturday afternoon in 90* temperatures. No wonder ingredients are slimy and spoiled. Poor attention to detail, I'm canceling.
  • Submitted By April on 06/13/2018
    My husband and I have been using Plated since October of 2016, roughly around 360 meals to date. We began our box delivery service with HelloFresh and then Blue Apron and finally landed on Plated. At first, the meals were extremely time-consuming and difficult. I am a teacher and my husband is in sales, so coming home after 13 hour days and having to cook a meal that took me over an hour just wasn't going to cut it. However, I stuck with them a little longer because their food was delicious and this is the only company that we had tried, thus far, that offered so many options. We have now been using them going on two years and I have no plans to stop. They have adjusted their recipes so that they are not so time consuming and require so much prep; they have also added a ton of recipe choices including yummy desserts! Yes, they may be a tad more expensive, but in my opinion, it's worth it because the food is always fresh and delicious! Plated also has AMAZING customer service. If there is absolutely anything wrong with any of your ingredients, no matter how small the ingredient, they will credit your account no questions asked. If you have allergies, Plated always lists all allergens on their recipe cards and on the website or app when you are selecting your recipes. They offer vegetarian, low-cal/carb, and gluten free options as well. I highly recommend this company and I can only see them getting better each year!
  • Submitted By Robyn IarobyncoaRngeli on 03/28/2018
    I ordered for the 1st time. Waited all day- Started a chat at 7:45 to let them know nothing has been delivered. Told me to wait until 8:00. Reached out again at 8:01. Going back and forth finally got a credit back to me, only that it will take 5-7 business days. Fedex - stated at 8:15 that the business was closed. This was a condo delivery. Called fed-ex not helpful. Contacted Plated again - it will be my descretion if I choose the food upon arrival. Completely unacceptable! Cancelled my subscription immediately. Very Poor - I do not want to give them a 1 star - completely below standards.
  • Submitted By Tammy on 03/24/2018
    I used Plated for a couple of years and enjoyed. When they were bought out this year the meat .... beef was less quality cut and the package was 2 ice packs instead of 4 packs.. It looked like getting less for the same price.. the original plated company always cared about your comments and concerns.......new owners never replied to my concerns. I no longer purchase Plated meals.
HelloFresh
  • Submitted By Kaylyn Morgan on 06/21/2018
    I have had a HelloFresh subscription for a year or so... with that being said HelloFresh really does offer some awesome recipes and I always enjoy their glazed. The more I have gotten into using HelloFresh the more I have increasingly became frustrated by meats leaking out everywhere, soggy bags, and frankly your just paying to much money to have your meals potentially ruined. It really wasn’t wouldn’t have been such a problem had it not happened nearly on a weekly basis. I’m a little sad to leave HelloFresh as their meals are tasty but it’s not worth the money. I’m going to try some other meal kit delivery services and see how that goes. I’m starting out with every plate which is WAY CHEAPER.
  • Submitted By Miriam Lindley on 06/20/2018
    Due to a coupon I went in to see the meals they had and I did not like any of them as I’m on a low carb diet. So I deactivated the account. It showed deactivated as I checked it. I then got the meals anyway. When I called customer service they said that I reactivated them. That is not true why would I reactivated meals I did not want. But the major problem was their customer service. The guy that I spoke to was beyond rude, would not listen to me at all, kept interrupting me and calling was belligerent. I had to ask for his supervisor because it was impossible to talk to him. I will never use them again. And the food they sent was not like the food from HomeChef. Not very good meals.
  • Submitted By Beth on 06/07/2018
    Totally disappointed with their business model. What a scam. They hook you in and make it difficult to unsubscribe. I thought I did and because of that I did not create an order for the next week. A package came anyway (to our vacation address so the next lucky renters got some food I have to pay for). I have many allergies in my house and need to make sure what comes is edible for everyone. I called customer and got absolutely no where.
  • Submitted By Jennifer on 06/03/2018
    I have been ordering Hello Fresh for several months now and I generally satisfied. I find that the recipes are pretty good. I am however sick and tired of taking a meal out of the fridge 4 days later and seeing that the meat is passed the ''best by''. I would expect to be able to make and eat a meal without having to worry about the meat being expired especially if it's before the next order arrives.

Winner

Plated is a meal kit delivery service that offers very flexible subscription plans, as well as high-quality foods. Each week, it comes up with a new seasonal menu, including 20 new recipes and 2 desserts, easily meeting the needs of its customers. Read our thorough analysis of the Plated meal kit service and dozens of user-written Plated reviews.

Meal Options

With both Plated and HelloFresh, you get to choose different meal options for you and your family according to your dietary needs, budget, and other important factors.

If you go with Plated, you don’t have to opt for a specific meal plan. Instead of meal plans, they offer a great variety of new recipes every week, including vegetarian options and desserts. You can choose to get amazing recipes for 2, 3 or 4 days of the week. You can order 2 servings for a romantic dinner, 3 for a small gathering or 4 for a family dinner.

Hello Fresh provides 3 meal plans for your dietary needs: Classic, Vegetarian, and Family. The Classic plan and the Veggie plan offer 2 or 4 servings. Every meal from the Family plan comes in 4 servings.

Variety

Both companies provide new creative recipes every week, meaning there are dishes for everyone’s taste.

Plated offers 12 innovative main course recipes, plus 8 encore recipes and 2 delicious desserts weekly. You can choose between hearty beef, mouthwatering salmon, or delicious salad, as Plated always has a recipe for you sensitive palate.

Hello Fresh also introduces 12 new dinner recipes every week. You can select 3 out of 6 palatable dishes from the Classic menu or let the professional team behind HelloFresh choose 3 vegetarian meals for you or 3 delicious dinners for your family.

Nutritional Value

Plated and Hello Fresh both provide you with the best ingredients available for healthy, well-balanced meals.

Plated provides high-quality ingredients for your home-cooked dinners. You can select any recipe from the menu according to your dietary preferences. Every recipe contains detailed information on the nutritional value of the meal, which can help you choose dishes suited for your diet.

HelloFresh cooperates with reliable food producers in order to bring the best ingredients to your table. Every meal is carefully planned and all the recipes include the number of calories of the chosen meal.

Portion Size

Both companies pay close attention to the preparation of the ingredients for your meals.

Everything you receive from Plated is carefully measured to satisfy the belly of a grown-up or 2 kids.

HelloFresh prepares recipes for the Family plan in order to provide enough food for 2 adults and 2 children while each serving from the Classic or Vegetarian plan is tailored for an adult.

Flexibility

You don’t have to worry about flexibility with either of these two companies. They both allow you to skip a delivery or cancel your subscription whenever suits you. You just need to notify them before your next order is processed.

Price

Compared to Plated, the prices of Hello Fresh meals are slightly lower. Also, with HelloFresh, shipping is always free. Every serving from both the Classic and Veggie Plan costs $9.99 while dinners from the Family Plan cost $8.74 per portion.

On the other hand, Plated is a bit more expensive than Hello Fresh. If you are cooking for 2 people, the price is $11.95 per serving while meals with 3 or 4 servings cost $9.99 per serving. Shipping is free on orders over $60.

Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.