Dinnerly VS FreshDirect Comparison

UPDATED May. 2019
Table Of Contents+
This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close

Bring some freshness and creativity to your everyday meals by picking a great meal delivery service. Both services offer innovative and healthy meals at reasonable prices. Check out our comprehensive Dinnerly VS FreshDirect comparison to learn more about both services and choose the best option for your family.

Dinnerly
Great Meal Kits At The Best Price
VS
FreshDirect
More Options Than You Ever Imagined

Highlights

Dinnerly
Dinnerly allows you to save both time and cash and enjoy delicious homecooked meals without spending more than 30 minutes in the kitchen.
  • Average Price Per Meal: $4.99
  • Shipping Cost: $8.99
  • Delivery Area: 29 states
FreshDirect
FreshDirect is a huge marketplace filled with fresh food items, ranging from meals and meal kits to groceries, baked goods, and treats of all sorts, all natural and reasonably priced.
  • Average Price Per Meal: $4.99
  • Shipping Cost: $5.99 *
  • Delivery Area: 6 states
*the costs vary from $5.99 to $15.99 depending on location

Compare Features

Dinnerly
Best For
Best for home cooks on a budget
Menu/Meal Plans
Dinnerly offers one menu that changes on a weekly basis.
Recipes/Meal Options
Dinnerly provides 8 meal options on its menu every week.
Meal & Recipe Variety
Dinnerly offers kid-friendly, vegan-friendly, vegetarian-friendly, low-carb, low-calorie, gluten-free, and dairy-free dinner recipes. You can also opt for one-pot and under-30-minutes recipes. However, keep in mind that not all of these options are available at all times. The meals are mostly classics and crowdpleasers.
Food Quality
Dinnerly sources only the best, freshest ingredients. It provides natural fruit and veg, grass-fed beef, antibiotic-free chicken, American-caught shrimp, and many other healthy, high-quality products.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
The meals you make with Dinnerly normally have between 600 and 800 calories per serving, although some hearty meals may have 900+ calories per serving. The portions are large enough to keep you satiated for hours and they contain the right proportions of carbs, proteins, and fats.
Subscription Flexibility
Dinnerly offers plenth of flexibility to its patrons, allowing you to change, skip, pause or cancel your order whenever you wish. Any changes to your subscription must be made 5 or 6 days before your next delivery, depending on your location.
Refunds
As Dinnerly features a freshness and quality guarantee, you can contact the company within 7 days of your delivery date for a refund or credit.
FreshDirect
Best For
Best for individuals looking for a one-stop shop for all their dietary needs
Menu/Meal Plans
Fresh Direct provides its customers with several ordering options, including meal kits, ready-made meals, and various food items.
Recipes/Meal Options
With Fresh Direct, you have thousands of food items, hundreds of dishes, and around 30 meal kits at your disposal.
Meal & Recipe Variety
FreshDirect offers omnivore, vegetarian, organic, low-calorie low-carb, low-fat, and gluten-free meals and meal kits. Its ready-made dishes include breakfasts, entrées, sides, appetizers, and soups, as well as a variety of sauces, marinades, salsas, dips, salads, pizzas, sandwiches, wraps, marinated meats, kabobs, and even sushi. You can also purchase groceries, pastry, and beverages.
Food Quality
Although FreshDirect offers a vast variety of different products, what they all have in common is that they are fresh and generally made of high-quality, natural, and organic ingredients.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
As FreshDirect offers over 3,000 food items and hundreds of meals, nutritional value and portion size vary significantly. However, since the company uses natural and organic ingredients, the products are generally healthy and rich in nutrients.
Subscription Flexibility
If you wish to modify or cancel your order with FreshDirect, you can do it at any time, but you must notify the company before the cutoff date, which depends on your location.
Refunds
If you are not happy with your order from FreshDirect, contact the company straight away and you will either get a replacement or refund.

Suitable For

Dinnerly
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One
FreshDirect
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One

Compare Meal Options

Dinnerly
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals
FreshDirect
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals

Compare Sample Meals

Dinnerly
FreshDirect

Compare Extras

Dinnerly
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace
FreshDirect
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace

Compare Ratings

Dinnerly
FINAL RATING
8.9/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price
FreshDirect
FINAL RATING
8.0/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price

Compare Customer Reviews

Dinnerly
  • Submitted By Jessica on 05/08/2019
    We enjoyed our first week of Dinnerly - the meals were good and we were happy to try a second week.Unfortunately we were missing ingredients from all three recipes in our second box. We contacted customer service and they offered a small partial refund. Since ingredients were missing from every recipe, we requested a full refund and spoke with a manager. They replied that they could only give the small refund. Due to the delay of needing to go to the store for missing ingredients (we don't live near a grocery store), additional ingredients went bad before we were able to make all three meals.What is the point of having a meal subscription service if I have to anticipate there will be missing ingredients and plan to not be able to make the recipes with what they send? I have seen a lot of reviews, even from people who like the service, that mention missing ingredients so it seems this is not a rare occurrence.
  • Submitted By Rachel on 05/07/2019
    This is the second boxed meal service that I've tried, and at first glance I'm not impressed. I had to sign up and pay first to see what recipes I could pick from; okay. Got to the recipes page and none of them were things that my boyfriend or I would eat. So I cancel it immediately, but am told that I will still be charged for the first box anyways. So I pick the 3 most likely meals that will be edible for us. They arrive on our day of choice (the only advantage this one has) and I open the box. Unlike other services, the recipe cards or instructions are not included. The only access to the recipes are on the website, and also unlike other services, there are no helpful pictures or videos with the instructions. Glad that I cancelled immediately; I would say that you get what you pay for, but I'm currently with a much better service for the same price.
  • Submitted By Bri on 04/25/2019
    I was excited to try this. Most meals were decent. I got it for four weeks. However, my deliveries kept getting pushed back. This most recent one was scheduled to be delivered two days late. Sorry, but I’m not eating food that may or may not still be on ice two days late.I emailed the customer service that said they would respond in 24 hours. Didn’t happen. I called customer service the next day and the lady that helped me was wonderful. She reimbursed me for the whole box. I ended up canceling my membership. Although I wasn’t a fan of every dish I made, I thought I could deal with it. Now with the food being delivered late, not worth it.
  • Submitted By sue kelley on 04/17/2019
    I've been using Dinnerly for the past 3 weeks and we are impressed with the taste and value. I was afraid that the serving portions would be too small but that has not been the case at all. First box was missing a couple common ingredients , but since everything has been there. They are easy to prepare and quick and easy. I work 12 hour shifts, so this is awesome as I don't feel like cooking a complicated meal. Dinnerly takes away the drudge of deciding what to cook, and keeps us from eating fast food. Way worth the cost !
FreshDirect
  • Submitted By Henry Giles on 07/22/2017
    I’m a lazy guy, so this kind of store is exactly what I need. Groceries – they’ve got ‘em, meals – so many options, beer – hell yeah.
  • Submitted By Laura Forbes on 05/05/2017
    Sure, it’s convenient, but it’s not as good as it’s hyped up to be.
  • Submitted By Hannah Rogers 3.5 on 03/14/2017
    The food’s awesome, but it’s too pricy if you ask me.

Winner

Dinnerly is the latest addition to the meal kit market, created for all those who wanted to give meal kits a try but found the usual prices to be too high. Inspired by numerous positive Dinnerly reviews, we have decided to explore the Dinnerly menu, subscriptions, and pricing and discover all the reasons for this company’s fast-growing popularity.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices. Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.
Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.