Meat The Butchers VS Carnivore Club Comparison

UPDATED Oct. 2019
Table Of Contents+
This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close

No one understands how important it is to choose the right meal delivery service better than we do. That is why we are here to help you make the best possible choice. While both Carnivore Club and Meat The Butchers offer delicious dishes and rather flexible subscriptions, there is much more to be considered before you make the final call. This Carnivore Club VS Meat The Butchers comparison allows you to get to know these companies better, discover their greatest advantages and shortcomings, and of course, find out which one provides a bit higher quality of service.

Carnivore Club
Your Monthly Dose Of Artisan Charcuterie
VS
Meat The Butchers
Premium Meats For Epicurious Carnivores

Highlights

Carnivore Club
Carnivore Club allows you to enjoy regular deliveries of premium cured meats handcrafted by trusted artisans. You can get curated boxes filled with small-batch charcuterie or meat snacks every month or shop for delicious meat treats at your leisure.
  • Price Range: $$
  • Shipping Cost: $9.99
  • Delivery Area: 50 states
Meat The Butchers
Meat The Butchers is a reliable supplier of fresh and natural beef, pork, lamb, and poultry. It only offers the highest-grade meats, its rich offer includes sushi-grade seafood, and its ordering system is perfectly flexible.
  • Price Range: $$
  • Average Price Per Meal: $11.00
  • Shipping Cost: $0 *
  • Delivery Area: 50 states
*for orders over $75 to $350

Compare Features

Carnivore Club
Best For
Best for fans of cured meat
Meat Selection
Carnivore Club delivers all kinds of salami, sausage, prosciutto, jerky, bacon, and other tasty charcuterie items.
Meat Quality
Carnivore Club provides exclusive, small-batch cured meats of high quality. Every item in its offer is handcrafted and made of all-natural meat.
Other Products
Apart from meat, Carnivore Club provides pantry and kitchen essentials.
Sourcing Practices
Carnivore Club only cooperates with select artisans that boast unique offers and use premium meats.
Flexibility
With Carnivore Club, the monthly, bi-monthly, and quarterly subscriptions come with a 3-box minimum and can be canceled after the third delivery. For customers who prefer their orders to come with no strings attached, the company offers the Try It Out option as well as one-time purchases.
Refunds
Carnivore Club offers replacements for damaged goods and refunds for accidental duplicate orders.
Shipping Costs
Carnivore Club charges a flat $9.99 shipping fee per delivery.
Delivery Area
Carnivore Club ships to all 50 US states, as well as Armed Forces locations, Canada, the UK, the European Union, and Australia.
Meat The Butchers
Best For
Best for fans of dry-aged beef
Meat Selection
Meat The Butchers offers over 70 different cuts at all times, including USDA Prime, Wagyu beef, and beef that is naturally dry-aged for 28 days, as well as all-natural chicken, quail, turkey, pork, and lamb.
Meat Quality
Meat The Butchers exclusively offers Upper Choice and Prime grade meats, thus ensuring that the meat that reaches your home is always of premium quality.
Other Products
In addition to premium meats, Meat The Butchers provides fresh seafood and pantry items like glazes and marinades.
Sourcing Practices
Meat The Butchers sources meat from family-owned farms and ranches that employ humane raising practices and adhere to high standards of sustainability. Its poultry is free-range and its red meat is corn-fed and grass-fed, never grain-fed.
Flexibility
Meat The Butchers allows you to shop commitment-free, with no minimum order. Its flexible meat subscriptions are currently unavailable.
Refunds
If you have an issue with your order, you can reach out to Meat The Butchers customer service via email or phone. Refunds are not guaranteed.
Shipping Costs
Meat The Butchers offers free shipping on larger orders. The free shipping threshold ranges from $75 to $350 and depends on location.
Delivery Area
Meat The Butchers ships throughout the continental US.

Meat Types

Carnivore Club
Beef
Pork
Lamb
Chicken
Turkey
Duck
Quail
Elk
Venison
Bison
Rabbit
Charcuterie
Organs
Bones
Fat
Meat The Butchers
Beef
Pork
Lamb
Chicken
Turkey
Duck
Quail
Elk
Venison
Bison
Rabbit
Charcuterie
Organs
Bones
Fat

Compare Ratings

Carnivore Club
FINAL RATING
8.8/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price
Meat The Butchers
FINAL RATING
8.5/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price

Compare Customer Reviews

Carnivore Club
  • Submitted By Tim Lopez on 06/11/2019
    Got CC as a gift from my gf, amazing quality but when I found out how much it costs, I gave up on getting a subscription. Yeah, it's great, but way too expensive.
  • Submitted By Richard Hess on 02/14/2019
    As far as I'm concerned, worth every penny. Never in my life have I tasted better beef jerky.
  • Submitted By Tien Hunt on 01/22/2019
    Got 2 boxes so far, loved every single bite. Hope they keep up the good work, I could really get used to this.
Meat The Butchers
  • Submitted By Tom Stein on 02/14/2018
    Real meat, fresh, perfectly marbled. If you know your meat, you can taste the difference right away, this is the real stuff, not the crap they sell at the stores. My warmest recommendation.
  • Submitted By Anna Baylor on 09/22/2017
    I saw the gorgeous MTB tenderloin on Facebook and just had to buy it for my hubby's birthday. It was out of this world, but the prices are really high, so waiting for our anniversary to shop again :D

Winner

If you love charcuterie in all its delicious forms, you may have heard of Carnivore Club, a monthly meat subscription service that offers exclusive selections of artisan cured meats. It allows you to discover new meat snacks and charcuterie products every month. If this sounds good, you can discover more tasty facts in our full Carnivore Club review.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices. Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.
Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.