Pantry Boy VS Marley Spoon

UPDATED Aug. 2018
Table Of Contents+

If you’d like to start eating healthier but don’t have time to cook, meal delivery services may be the perfect solution to your problem! Check out or objective Pantry Boy VS Marley Spoon comparison to get a better idea of what these two services offer and determine which one is the right choice for you and your family.

Pantry Boy
Easy & Healthy Gourmet Cooking
VS
Marley Spoon
Home Cooking With Martha Stewart

Highlights

Pantry Boy
Pantry Boy is a competitively-priced, time-saving home cooking solution that allows you to make gourmet meals with virtually no effort.
  • Average Price Per Meal: $9.69
  • Shipping Cost: $0
  • Delivery Area: 27 states
Marley Spoon
Marley Spoon provides unique meal kits crafted in cooperation with Martha Stewart, suitable for both vegetarian and omnivorous foodies, competitively priced, and designed with all cooking skill levels in mind.
  • Average Price Per Meal: $9.00
  • Shipping Cost: $0
  • Delivery Area: 48 states

Compare Features

Pantry Boy
Best For
Best for fans of quick-prep, slow-simmer recipes
Menu/Meal Plans
Pantry Boy has one menu divided into 3 parts, including Carnivore, Omnivore, and Vegetarian.
Recipes/Meal Options
Pantry Boy offers its customers 6 new recipes each week.
Meal & Recipe Variety
Pantry Boy offers slow-cooker and gourmet recipes inspired by the season and various world cuisines. Its recipes are designed with carnivores, omnivores, and vegetarians in mind. They are suitable for all cooking skill levels and the hands-on time is reduced to the bare minimum. The meals can be customized to accommodate various dietary restrictions.
Food Quality
Pantry Boy delivers farm-fresh seasonal ingredients. Its produce is organic whenever possible, locally sourced, and always free from GMOs. Its meat is free from antibiotics and growth hormones. Everything is free from preservatives.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
The average calorie count for Pantry Boy meals is around 700 calories per serving. The meals come in medium-to-large portions and they are rather satisfying. They are nutrient-rich and often optimally balanced.
Subscription Flexibility
With Pantry Boy, you can switch between plans, skip a week or cancel your subscription at any time. However, you must notify the company of your changes by 11:59PM 5 days before your next delivery is due.
Refunds
For any information about refunds, you should contact Pantry Boy directly.
Marley Spoon
Best For
Best for people who want to cook like Martha Stewart
Menu/Meal Plans
Marley Spoon has opted to include one menu in its offer, which is further divided into the 2-People and 3-4 People boxes based on the number of servings you would like to order.
Recipes/Meal Options
Each week, Marley Spoon offers 10 new recipes on its weekly menu.
Meal & Recipe Variety
Marley Spoon offers easy dinner recipes for couples and families. Its menu includes gluten-free, vegetarian, omnivore, and kid-friendly recipes. Most dishes are ready in 30-40 minutes. The recipes are highly innovative.
Food Quality
Marley Spoon provides the freshest, sustainably sourced produce, high-quality fish, grass-fed beef, Berkshire pork, antibiotic-free chicken, and artisanal products made by small-batch producers who use local ingredients.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
The meals you make with Marley Spoon are highly satisfying and usually contain 650 to 900 calories. They are rich in nutrients and nutritionally balanced in accordance with the rules of healthy eating.
Subscription Flexibility
With Marley Spoon, you can switch between boxes, change your order, and skip, pause or cancel your delivery anytime, but you must inform the company of your changes 5 days before your next delivery is due.
Refunds
Marley Spoon boasts an awesome freshness and quality guarantee, so if you are not satisfied with your order, you may either recieve a credit or a partial or full refund.

Compare Plans & Pricing

Pantry Boy
Pantry Boy Plans & Pricing
Two Person Plan (2 servings)
Meals per weekMeal kit pricePrice per serving
3 carnivore meals$62.34$10.39
3 omnivore meals$58.14$9.69
3 vegetarian meals$53.94$8.99
Four Person Plan (4 servings)
Meals per weekMeal kit pricePrice per serving
3 carnivore meals$124.68$10.39
3 omnivore meals$116.28$9.69
3 vegetarian meals$107.88$8.99
Marley Spoon
Marley Spoon Plans & Pricing
Two Person Plan (2 servings)
Meals per weekMeal kit pricePrice per serving
2$48.00$12.00
3$61.50$10.25
4$76.00$9.50
3-4 People Plan (3-4 servings)
Meals per weekMeal kit pricePrice per serving
2$76.00$9.50
3$106.80$8.90
4$131.20$8.20

Suitable For

Pantry Boy
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One
Marley Spoon
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One

Compare Meal Options

Pantry Boy
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals
Marley Spoon
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals

Compare Sample Meals

Pantry Boy
Marley Spoon

Compare Extras

Pantry Boy
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace
Marley Spoon
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace

Compare Ratings

Pantry Boy
FINAL RATING
8.7/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price
Marley Spoon
FINAL RATING
9.2/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price

Compare User Reviews

Pantry Boy
  • Submitted By Peggy Cairns on 07/02/2018
    Went out of business with no communication to customers, and some customers are out thousands of dollars!
  • Submitted By 06/27/2018
    Do you what happens to all the people who got a year subscription, are we all just out all That money now that they ate closed
  • Submitted By Kara Fulton on 05/06/2018
    If I were Pantry Boy, I'd be embarrassed by my product. Rather than go into all of the specifics of each meal, here are some general trends. 1) Meals are horribly bland, sometimes to the point of being inedible - yes, we've opted to throw meals away and make something else for dinner, what a waste. It's as if the recipes were developed by someone who has never tasted food before. I've had dollar store microwave meals that taste better. 2) Every meal had something wrong with the ingredients, often more that one thing wrong (e.g., meat that was supposed to be marinated but wasn't, missing ingredients, spoiled ingredients, ingredients spilled out of their packaging onto others). 3) Directions are inconsistent and, sometimes, contradictory. 4) Recipe photo in no way depicts what you actually receive. 5) One box was barely cold - everything would have been spoiled had it sat on my porch for even an hour longer. I have tried other meal delivery services and Pantry Boy is, by far, the worst I have ever experienced. Ultimately, I wish I wouldn't have wasted my money on this poor excuse for a meal delivery service.
  • Submitted By James on 12/02/2017
    Pantryboy meals are the best value of any of the dozen or so meal services we’ve tried. The prep is easiest, period. Nice full portions too. There’s usually at least one wow recipe per box. We bought a whole year subscription making the price very attractive.
Marley Spoon
  • Submitted By Tori Swejk
    This company has horrible customer service, which is not good as they can't seem to ship boxes properly. I personally received a broken box, with meat and ice packs broken and red goo all over everything (gel+meat juice = gross). a friend of mine tried and her meat came spoiled. If you look at marley spoon's facebook (what they dont delete anyways) there are pictures of moldy food, and countless stories of bad customer service and spoiled meat. I am personally blocked and my review deleted. I ordered a box and recieved it 7/25. it was my second box, i paid full price. It was busted and i promptly contacted customer service. i was told i'd get a refund and a free box for the inconvenience. refund in 7-10 days. I was traveling so i skipped a few boxes. 10 business days go by- no refund. I contact them again. They tell me OOPS we had a mistake we will issue it now. Friday comes along, and I got charged for my "free" box. That was it, patience over, guns blazing. I posted my story all over, customer service was rude to me when i asked why i was charged for my free box... i was livid. They blocked me and deleted my review on facebook. Still no refund. I shared my story on my facebook page and people went to their facebook and reshared my review (i'm still blocked). I eventually filed a paypal claim since I THANKFULLY paid that way for the busted box. Customer service has been sending me emails and i responded and alerted them of the paypal dispute, and they told me "they couldnt issue my refund unless I canceled the claim". 1) my refund was supposed to have already been issued. if thats the case, they can put that in paypal and it will close the claim. 2) asking me to cancel a paypal claim would void my protection and leave them in the position to never have to refund me. I posted about this as well, with many facebook friends chiming in that they will now never use this service. a few hours later, no more word from marley spoon, and now i have a refund on paypal! I didnt even have to wait 7-10 more days
  • Submitted By Krista Barnes on 08/01/2018
    Only one star since 0 isn’t an option. Terrible. I am a member of 4 meal kit deliveries this is the worst. First off, the food is never delivered as cold as my other kits. Also the packing material is subpar compared to other kits. Paper bags stuffed with insulation type filling that was ripped and spilled all over my food. Received my first two orders, then skipped a week due to leaving for vacation, but SUPRISE! I was still charged and received a box of food. Customer service did nothing to assist offered no resolution. I contacted them prior to receiving my box (once I saw an email stating my box would be shipping) and nothing was addressed. All the recipes in the box I didn’t order are nothing I want to eat. Pricing most expensive meal kit after your initial little discount you receive.
  • Submitted By Bill on 07/30/2018
    Bait and Switch!!! I heard Martha offer 3 Free meals, never once mentioned a credit towards 6 meals!!! Shame on you Martha!!! I felt bad when Martha was sent to prison, perhaps she deserved it!!!
  • Submitted By Teresa Finley on 07/27/2018
    I have been a customer for 5 weeks. This has been my first experience with a meal delivery subscription. The food was wonderful. What I received that was safe to eat. Plus delivery was a major, major issue. The very first delivery, I received after 11 pm on my delivery day of Wednesday. It included all listed ingredients and both my husband and myself were surprisingly thrilled. We agreed to make these recipes ourselves. Because I was concerned about my box being late I did contact customer service via email and was given a ten dollar credit. Week 2 was a holiday week. My delivered was moved to Tuesday. It arrived in the middle of the day. All ingredients were included. We were happy with our menu choices, but it was unlikely we would cook these on our own. Week 3 my delivery arrived a day late, We loved one of the meals, but the second one was just not pleasing to our taste buds. Due to the delivery arriving a full day late, I was again given a ten dollar credit from customer service via an e mail conversation. Week 4. My delivery was a day late, again. But this time I wasn't home to receive it. So it sat outside all morning. In the summer heat of Las Vegas. I called once again. Because the protein and all cold items were warm and the ice packs were completely melted they did give me a credit for the full amount. I told customer service that if it happened again, I would cancel the service. They were very helpful and friendly. My only issue was actually getting through on the phone. I was hung up on by the auto service twice because they were too busy to help me. I was advised by "Martha Stewart" to try again later. Click. Week 4 rolls around. I had changed my delivery day to Tuesday, hoping that it would arrive on time. Nope. Again a day late and well past dinner time this time. We had pizza delivered. It was pretty good, but not what I was looking for. My box was warm and all items were unsafe. But I had already called customer service, after unsubscribing on line, and a very nice man listened to my complaints. He was my 2nd call because the first woman gave me incorrect information about tracking my delivery. Something I had asked about previously and received no answer on. Due to the time and the info the CS rep was able to find regarding tracking, he gave me a full refund, not a credit. I had stated that I believed my box had spent at least a day and a half sitting in a warehouse without air conditioning then loaded on a truck, also without air conditioning. He didn't make me wait for my delivery so I didn't have to call back. Once again the box items were warm and the ice packs were melted. I just might try this again, but never in the summertime. I loved the recipes we were able to make and am disappointed in the offerings from other services. So come fall, I will give them another shot, to see if they have fixed the delivery schedule issue.

Winner

Marley Spoon is a meal kit delivery that brings you world-famous recipes created by Martha Stewart, transformed into 6-step instructions everyone can follow. Along with the recipes, you get flavor-packed, farm-fresh, pre-measured ingredients. Discover more in our honest review of the service and 50+ customer-written Martha and Marley Spoon reviews.

Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.