Pantry Boy VS FreshDirect

UPDATED May. 2018
Table Of Contents+

If you’d like to start eating healthier but don’t have time to cook, meal delivery services may be the perfect solution to your problem! Check out or objective Pantry Boy VS FreshDirect comparison to get a better idea of what these two services offer and determine which one is the right choice for you and your family.

Pantry Boy
Easy & Healthy Gourmet Cooking
VS
FreshDirect
More Options Than You Ever Imagined

Highlights

Pantry Boy
Pantry Boy is a competitively-priced, time-saving home cooking solution that allows you to make gourmet meals with virtually no effort.
  • Average Price Per Meal: $9.69
  • Shipping Cost: $0
  • Delivery Area: 27 states
FreshDirect
FreshDirect is a huge marketplace filled with fresh food items, ranging from meals and meal kits to groceries, baked goods, and treats of all sorts, all natural and reasonably priced.
  • Average Price Per Meal: $20.00
  • Shipping Cost: $6.99
  • Delivery Area: 6 states

Compare Features

Pantry Boy
Best For
Best for fans of quick-prep, slow-simmer recipes
Menu/Meal Plans
Pantry Boy has one menu divided into 3 parts, including Carnivore, Omnivore, and Vegetarian.
Recipes/Meal Options
Pantry Boy offers its customers 6 new recipes each week.
Meal & Recipe Variety
Pantry Boy offers slow-cooker and gourmet recipes inspired by the season and various world cuisines. Its recipes are designed with carnivores, omnivores, and vegetarians in mind. They are suitable for all cooking skill levels and the hands-on time is reduced to the bare minimum. The meals can be customized to accommodate various dietary restrictions.
Food Quality
Pantry Boy delivers farm-fresh seasonal ingredients. Its produce is organic whenever possible, locally sourced, and always free from GMOs. Its meat is free from antibiotics and growth hormones. Everything is free from preservatives.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
The average calorie count for Pantry Boy meals is around 700 calories per serving. The meals come in medium-to-large portions and they are rather satisfying. They are nutrient-rich and often optimally balanced.
Subscription Flexibility
With Pantry Boy, you can switch between plans, skip a week or cancel your subscription at any time. However, you must notify the company of your changes by 11:59PM 5 days before your next delivery is due.
Refunds
For any information about refunds, you should contact Pantry Boy directly.
FreshDirect
Best For
Best for individuals looking for a one-stop shop for all their dietary needs
Menu/Meal Plans
Fresh Direct provides its customers with several ordering options, including meal kits, ready-made meals, and various food items.
Recipes/Meal Options
With Fresh Direct, you have thousands of food items, hundreds of dishes, and around 40 meal kits at your disposal.
Meal & Recipe Variety
FreshDirect offers omnivore, vegetarian, vegan, organic, low-calorie low-carb, low-fat, and gluten-free meals and meal kits. Its ready-made dishes include breakfasts, entrées, sides, appetizers, and soups, as well as a variety of sauces, marinades, salsas, dips, salads, pizzas, sandwiches, wraps, marinated meats, kabobs, and even sushi. You can also purchase groceries, pastry, and beverages.
Food Quality
Although FreshDirect offers a vast variety of different products, what they all have in common is that they are fresh and generally made of high-quality, natural, and organic ingredients.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
As FreshDirect offers over 3,000 food items and hundreds of meals, nutritional value and portion size vary significantly. However, since the company uses natural and organic ingredients, the products are generally healthy and rich in nutrients.
Subscription Flexibility
If you wish to modify or cancel your order with FreshDirect, you can do it at any time, but you must notify the company before the cutoff date, which depends on your location.
Refunds
If you are not happy with your order from FreshDirect, contact the company straight away and you will either get a replacement or refund.

Suitable For

Pantry Boy
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One
FreshDirect
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One

Compare Meal Options

Pantry Boy
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals
FreshDirect
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals

Compare Sample Meals

Pantry Boy
FreshDirect

Compare Extras

Pantry Boy
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace
FreshDirect
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace

Compare Ratings

Pantry Boy
FINAL RATING
8.7/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price
FreshDirect
FINAL RATING
8.0/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price

Compare User Reviews

Pantry Boy
  • Submitted By Kara Fulton on 05/06/2018
    If I were Pantry Boy, I'd be embarrassed by my product. Rather than go into all of the specifics of each meal, here are some general trends. 1) Meals are horribly bland, sometimes to the point of being inedible - yes, we've opted to throw meals away and make something else for dinner, what a waste. It's as if the recipes were developed by someone who has never tasted food before. I've had dollar store microwave meals that taste better. 2) Every meal had something wrong with the ingredients, often more that one thing wrong (e.g., meat that was supposed to be marinated but wasn't, missing ingredients, spoiled ingredients, ingredients spilled out of their packaging onto others). 3) Directions are inconsistent and, sometimes, contradictory. 4) Recipe photo in no way depicts what you actually receive. 5) One box was barely cold - everything would have been spoiled had it sat on my porch for even an hour longer. I have tried other meal delivery services and Pantry Boy is, by far, the worst I have ever experienced. Ultimately, I wish I wouldn't have wasted my money on this poor excuse for a meal delivery service.
  • Submitted By James on 12/02/2017
    Pantryboy meals are the best value of any of the dozen or so meal services we’ve tried. The prep is easiest, period. Nice full portions too. There’s usually at least one wow recipe per box. We bought a whole year subscription making the price very attractive.
  • Submitted By Peter Atkins on 09/22/2017
    The ingredients are good, but I didn't like the meals the last couple of weeks. It's a shame they don't offer more options.
  • Submitted By Samantha Casey on 07/05/2017
    Pretty decent, but a soup hardly qualifies as a meal, they should offer soups separately and some good sides would be a nice addition too.
FreshDirect
  • Submitted By Henry Giles on 07/22/2017
    I’m a lazy guy, so this kind of store is exactly what I need. Groceries – they’ve got ‘em, meals – so many options, beer – hell yeah.
  • Submitted By Laura Forbes on 05/05/2017
    Sure, it’s convenient, but it’s not as good as it’s hyped up to be.
  • Submitted By Hannah Rogers 3.5 on 03/14/2017
    The food’s awesome, but it’s too pricy if you ask me.

Winner

Pantry Boy brings you top-notch ingredients straight from the farm, fresh, chopped, and trimmed, waiting for you to combine them into a masterpiece with the company’s easy-to-follow recipes. If you want to enrich your collection of slow cooker recipes and treat yourself to some fuss-free cooking, take a look at this detailed Pantry Boy review.

Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.