Freshly VS True Fare Comparison

UPDATED Oct. 2019
Table Of Contents+
This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close

Bring some freshness and creativity to your everyday meals by picking a great meal delivery service. Both services offer innovative and healthy meals at reasonable prices. Check out our comprehensive True Fare VS Freshly comparison to learn more about both services and choose the best option for your family.

True Fare
Top-Quality, Organic Whole30 Meals
VS
Freshly
Gourmet meals that keep you fit

Highlights

True Fare
True Fare, formerly known as Pre-Made Paleo, delivers wholesome, nutrient-dense Paleo meals suitable for various healthy diets and made of the finest, certified organic ingredients.
  • Price Range: $$
  • Average Price Per Meal: $12.70
  • Shipping Cost: $0 *
  • Delivery Area: 50 states
*free over $50
Freshly
Freshly offers reasonable prices and a rich menu filled with hallmarks of Italian and American cuisines, all made of fresh, natural ingredients.
  • Price Range: $
  • Average Price Per Meal: $9.99
  • Shipping Cost: $0
  • Delivery Area: 48 states

Compare Features

True Fare
Best For
Best for individuals on low-carb diets, Paleo lovers, and people who want to eat natural, organic food
Menu/Meal Plans
True Fare's menu features a number of options, including Whole30, AIP, and Ketogenic, as well as Spring Menus, Breakfast, Wild Caught Fish & Seafood, and A La Carte Individual Meals and Vegetable Sides.
Recipes/Meal Options
True Fare offers around 50 meal options for you to choose from.
Meal & Recipe Variety
True Fare offers organic, gluten-free, grain-free, legume-free, lactose-free, low-carb meals. Its menu includes Paleo-friendly, keto-friendly, Whole30-compliant, and AIP-friendly breakfasts, lunches, and dinners. In addition to standard meals, it offers exotic dishes made of venison, elk, wild boar, water buffalo, and alpaca meat.
Food Quality
True Fare sources certified organic produce grown on Georgia farms. It uses antibiotic-free, grass-fed, and grass-finished beef, free-range poultry, game meat, and wild-caught sefood. All of its meals are free from refined sugars and artificial substances.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
True Fare meals usually come in 6 oz. servings and rarely contain more than 350 calories per serving. They are nutritionally balanced and mostly free from trans fats but may contain significant amounts of cholesterol.
Subscription Flexibility
If you wish to cancel your True Fare subscription, you must do so 7 days before your renewal date. For all other questions about the service’s flexibility, you should contact True Fare directly.
Refunds
True Fare may issue refunds, but you must notify the company of your complaints within 24-48 hours after your delivery has arrived.
Freshly
Best For
Best for home diners who prefer classics and comfort food
Menu/Meal Plans
Freshly provides its customers with a weekly menu to choose from.
Recipes/Meal Options
Freshly offers 30+ lunch and dinner items on its menu every week.
Meal & Recipe Variety
Freshly offers chef-prepared entrées for different diets. Its menu includes low-carb, high-protein, Paleo, omnivore, vegetarian, gluten-free, soy-free, dairy-free, and calorie-conscious meals. It offers both classic and exotic dishes, most of them originating from the American and Italian cuisines, with occasional Asian dishes.
Food Quality
Freshly exclusively uses fresh, natural ingredients. Its meals never contain any artificial flavors or colors and they are free from gluten, added sugars, and preservatives.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
Most Freshly meals contain between 400 and 500 calories per serving. They are generally healthy and nutritionally balanced but they are not free from cholesterol and may contain more than 600 mg of sodium. The portions are usually around 13 oz.
Subscription Flexibility
With Freshly, you can change, skip, pause or cancel your order whenever you want. The deadline for making any changes is 11:59PM PST 5 days before your scheduled delivery day.
Refunds
If you are not satisfied with your delivery from Freshly, you may receive a full or partial refund or credit. You must report your complaints to the company within 5 days of your delivery date.

Compare Plans & Pricing

True Fare
True Fare Plans & Pricing
Regular Subscription Plans
Number of mealsPricePrice per meal
5$72.00$14.40
10$135.00$13.50
20$259.95$12.99
30$385.00$12.83
40$400.00$10.00
Whole30 Subscription Plans
DurationPricePrice per meal
10 days$349.00$11.63
15 days$509.00$11.31
20 days$675.00$11.25
30 days$995.00$11.05
AIP Subscription Plan
DurationPricePrice per meal
15 days$485.00$10.77
Freshly
Freshly Plans & Pricing
Meal Programs
Meals per weekPrice per weekPrice per meal
4$49.99$12.50
6$59.99$9.99
9$89.99$9.99
12$107.99$8.99

Suitable For

True Fare
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One
Freshly
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One

Compare Meal Options

True Fare
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals
Freshly
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals

Compare Extras

True Fare
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace
Freshly
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace

Compare Ratings

True Fare
FINAL RATING
9.4/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price
Freshly
FINAL RATING
9.8/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price

Compare Customer Reviews

True Fare
  • Submitted By Shannon Bathurst on 03/15/2018
    I received my 30 day fully prepared meals from True fare about 7 days ago. 30dayWhole challenge. Very simple. Pricey. But worth every dime. The price just makes me super committed to staying focused on the diet. The day I received the fully prepared meals...I got ziplock bags and went by the weekly menu and separated all 30 days into the bags. Marking them for each day and what week. That took time. But was well worth it. Then froze everything but first week. I received so much food that I even had 3 to four full bags of extra food left. Probably enough for another month or 30 days. I had started to prepare myself for this diet a week in advance. Reading all I could about it. So in one week plus the week I did preparation to be on this diet I have cut out all the sugars and processed foods and all recommended things to cut out. I Increased fresh vegetables and fruits. I have already lost in 2 weeks 10.5 pounds. Hoping to stay on diet until I loss the other 20 I need to lose. Then continue on my own making my own meals. My stomach no longer is upset everyday,I have more ambition and energy, even my back pain is going away. The prepared food is more than filling. Which totally surprised me. As I only put 3 bags in each zip lock bag and also supplement with the trail mix and fresh fruits or veggies if Im hungry. But I rarely am. This is the best I have ever felt on a diet...which feels like no diet at all. The only work involved was separating each days foods into the ziplock bags the day the food arrived. I love it and highly recommend it to anyone.
  • Submitted By Sunnie Thornton on 20/20/2018
    I have type II diabetes and last year my doctor recommended the Whole30 program to help me manage my diabetes. I attempted the Whole30 (made it through day 27) and was completely overwhelmed by the amount of cooking, food prep, shopping, cleaning, etc. I felt like I was spending an average of three hours in the kitchen each day, and that just does not work for my schedule. The added stress of this definitely hindered the positive effects of the program as most days my stress levels were extremely high causing unstable blood sugar.This year, in another attempt to get my blood sugars under control and to improve my health in general, I decided to do the Whole30 again but this time to save up my money and purchase the TrueFare 30-day Whole30 plan.I really expected to love it considering the price tag of $900.00 ($10/meal). I definitely love the convenience of it (the food is just so-so and lacks variety, which I could handle and wouldn’t be too big of a deal on its own), but there was a major problem that I have been going back and forth with TrueFare customer service on:The nutritional information varies on 1) the food labels (that are on each individual food packet), 2) the menu flyers (that are shipped with the food), and 3) on the online nutritional information posted on the website.Here is an example of the Pork Skillet: • PROTEIN: Package: 14g; Online: 23 g • CALORIES: Package: 240; Online: 330 • CARBS: Package: 9g; Online: 14 g • FAT: Package: 16g; Online: 20gHere is an example of the Chimichurri Chicken • PROTEIN: Package: 37g; Flyer: 29 g • CALORIES: Package: 310; Flyer: 280 • FAT: Package: 15g; Flyer: 12gAnother example of inconsistencies and errors: • The last meal at the bottom of Menu ‘R’ says “US Wellness Meats Grass-Fed Pink Peppercorn Braised Beef served with Organic Cauliflower Rice Pilaf.” • TrueFare prints the nutritional information on the back of the same flyer and the pairing for the beef is listed as “API Cauliflower Pilaf with Mushrooms.” • The label on the actual pairing I received was “Cauliflower Rice with Sweet Potatoes.” And of course, the nutritional information on the label obviously doesn’t match what’s on the back of the flyer. • The ingredients on the label state that there are brussels in the ingredients, but I definitely did not see any – just cauliflower and sweet potatoes.After multiple emails with TrueFare, Joseph admitted there was confusion and that they had some type of glitch / labeling issue as they were switching over from Pre-Made Paleo to TrueFare and that some products were mislabeled and incorrect. It was extremely time consuming emailing them or calling them trying to get a straight answer as to which nutritional label and ingredient lists were correct – and I’d have to do it for each discrepancy I came across. I finally gave up.On Whole30 you don’t typically track calories, macronutrients, etc., but since I am diabetic, tracking carbs is essential to my overall plan to figure out what works best for my body and I can eliminate the use of medications in controlling my blood sugar, and I stressed this fact to customer service.I communicated with TrueFare about this issue multiple times and also expressed my dissatisfaction with the issue at hand. I had asked that the *actual/correct* nutritional information for each meal be emailed to me, but that request was ignored. Nothing was done by TrueFare to rectify the situation and the only apology I got was a casual (and seemingly insincere) “sorry for the confusion.”Considering this plan was endorsed by Whole30, and considering the hefty price tag, I am highly disappointed with the issues I’ve experienced with this company and I question the integrity of what I’m eating.It would benefit TrueFare to take customer complaints more seriously and improve the customer service side of the business. I do not feel and adequate attempt was made to resolve or rectify the issues I had with my order, especially considering TrueFare was aware of the labeling issue yet continued to send food out anyway. $900 is a lot of money for most single people to spend on a months’ worth of food, and the lack of customer service and conflict resolution is truly disappointing.Unfortunately, I can’t recommend TrueFare until they are able to correct the labeling issues/glitches and improve their conflict resolution standards.
  • Submitted By Julian Keegan on 06/30/2017
    Not the cheapest, but definitely the best paleo meals I’ve ever had. Meal pairings are my favorite!
  • Submitted By Denis O’Connor on 05/21/2017
    I like the food, great options you’ve got over there. But I really get confused wandering around your site, pls do something about it.
Freshly
  • Submitted By Stephanie Corsano on 10/07/2019
    I have ordered Freshly meals for about 4 months now and I just love them! The food is tasty. Great portions and I am NEVER left hungry. They have a variety of meals that I like. They add or change to different meals periodically, but I definitely have my favorites. Some you may have to season a bit more as they try and keep things healthy (so maybe some salt on occasion), but for the majority, 3 min in the microwave and you’re good to go! I have had a few instances with the delivery people, but when I call customer service, they are friendly, helpful and accommodating. They have even credited me back for any issues that may have come up. I also like the fact that I can customize my order. A number of meals per week, rather than choosing from a number of breakfasts, lunches, and dinners. I can’t do breakfast or lunch because I commute for work, and I do not have a microwave there. So ordering dinners for the end of the evening, is the best! But they do offer it if you’re so inclined. Overall, they are worth a try. You won’t be disappointed. Hopefully they will expand how many meals they offer, but they definitely include enough variety for me!
  • Submitted By robb on 08/27/2019
    I am happy with the selection, quality, price. I will be staying long term, as long as they don't increase prices.
  • Submitted By Christina on 08/18/2019
    Freshly was not good, and not worth the cost. It didn't taste particularly healthy NOR good. I had to struggle to make my way through the rest of my initial 6-meal trial. I will certainly never order from Freshly again.
  • Submitted By SunnyDays on 06/20/2019
    I've been enjoying Freshly for a few months now and have to say they have exceeded my expectations. The meals arrive fully cooked and are kept cool in a well insulated box with earth friendly gel packs to keep them at a refrigerated temperature. They can go right into your fridge for later or pop one in the microwave for about 3 minuets and your dinner is ready. If you don't think you'll be eating them within the designated time listed on the package you can just freeze them and eat them when you're ready. ...

Winner

Freshly is a Paleo-inspired meal delivery service that brings you protein-packed, chef-prepared meals that are sure to keep you feeling full and energized throughout the day. If you are thinking about giving Freshly meals a try, be sure to read our detailed review of Freshly and check out Freshly reviews written by more or less satisfied customers.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices. Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.
Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.