BistroMD VS Magic Kitchen Comparison

UPDATED Aug. 2019
Table Of Contents+
This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close

The art of cooking isn't reserved for chefs only. With amazing recipes and carefully prepared ingredients from Bistro MD or Magic Kitchen, you can become a great chef yourself. How to choose whether Bistro MD or Magic Kitchen is better? Check out our honest comparison and find out everything you need to know about these two meal delivery services.

Bistro MD
Meal plans for healthy weight loss
VS
Magic Kitchen
Meals for all your dietary needs

Highlights

Bistro MD
With BistroMD, you can stop stressing about your weight and start shedding pounds by enjoying ready-made diet meals designed to suit your age, gender, and personal dietary needs.
  • Average Price Per Meal: $10.50
  • Shipping Cost: $19.95
  • Delivery Area: 50 states
Magic Kitchen
Magic Kitchen can satisfy all your dietary needs throughout the week and accommodate any allergies, special preferences or nutritional requirements you may have.
  • Average Price Per Meal: $10.00
  • Shipping Cost: $18.00-$20.00
  • Delivery Area: 50 states

Compare Features

Bistro MD
Best For
Best for dieters seeking a personalized weight loss solution
Menu/Meal Plans
BistroMD offers separate plans for men and women. Men can opt for the Men's Program, Gluten-Free Program, Vegetarian Program, Diabetic Program or Heart-Healthy plan. Women can choose from the Women's Program, Gluten-Free Program, Vegetarian Program, Diabetic Program, Menopause Program or Heart-Healthy plan.
Recipes/Meal Options
BistroMD has 150-200 meal options on the menu at all times.
Meal & Recipe Variety
Designed by doctors and prepared by professional chefs, BistroMD meals are healthy, nutritious, and suitable for heart-healthy, gluten-free, diabetic, menopause, and vegetarian diets. The service offers a vast assortment of breakfast, lunches, dinners, and healthy snacks and you are free to customize your menu.
Food Quality
All BistroMD diet meals are certified by the USDA. They are made of natural ingredients and contain no added MSG, aspartame or trans fats. The company carefully choses its suppliers and exclusively cooperates with farmers that employ sustainable farming methods.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
With BistroMD, your daily calorie intake is 1,100-1,400 calories. About 40-45% of calories come from lean protein, 30-35% come from complex carbohydrates, and 20-25% come from healthy fats. Thus, the dishes are scientifically-balanced, calorie-controlled, and nutrient-rich. The portions are rather large, keeping you full until your next meal.
Subscription Flexibility
With BistroMD, you can modify your subscription whenever you want. You can pause, skip or canel your order anytime as well. Bear in mind that all changes to your subscription must be made before Sunday at 12am ET for week 1 members. For all future weeks, you must make changes by Wednesday at 5pm ET the week prior to the week your delivery is due.
Refunds
If you are not satisfied with your delivery from BistroMD, you may either receive a credit or refund.
Magic Kitchen
Best For
Best for individuals with special dietary needs
Menu/Meal Plans
Magic Kitchen features two menus, including A La Carte and Complete Meals.
Recipes/Meal Options
Magic Kitchen's A La Carte menu features 40+ meal options whereas its Complete Meals Menu has 100+ items on offer.
Meal & Recipe Variety
Magic Kitchen offers omnivore, vegetarian, senior-friendly, portion-controlled, diabetic-friendly, low-sodium, low-carb, low-fat, renal-friendly, dialysis-friendly, dairy-free, and gluten-free complete meals. Its selection of individual dishes includes soups and breads, entrées, side dishes, and desserts. The service also offers meal bundles for easier ordering, such as 1-person, family-size, senior, homestyle, and dessert bundles.
Food Quality
Magic Kitchen promises to always use restaurant-quality products, source organic fruit and vegetables whenever possible, and exclusively feature pesticide-free, antibiotic-free, and hormone-free ingredients.
Nutritional Value & Portion Size
Magic Kitchen complete meals, including an entrée and 1-2 sides, usually have 350-550 calories. The meals are nutritionally balanced, often low in carbs, and generally suitable for individuals with an average appetite or those who could benefit from portion control.
Subscription Flexibility
Magic Kitchen boasts great flexibility. You can make changes to your order by contacting the company via phone or email.
Refunds
Magic Kitchen has a satisfaction guarantee, so if you are unsatisfied with your order, you may receive a credit or replacement.

Compare Plans & Pricing

Bistro MD
Bistro MD Plans & Pricing
Full Program
Days per weekPricePrice per meal
7$179.95 (first week $134.96)$8.99
5$149.95 (first week $112.46)$9.99
Lunches and Dinners
Days per weekPricePrice per meal
7$149.95 (first week $112.46)$10.71
5$119.95 (first week $89.96)$11.99
Magic Kitchen
Magic Kitchen Plans & Pricing
Individual Meals (2 servings)
MealPrice per meal
Breakfast$7.99 - $9.99
Lunch/Dinner$9.99 - $55.99
Snacks$7.99 - $13.99
Dessert$6.99 - $9.99
Meal Programs
Meals per dayPrice per weekPrice per meal
1$75.00 - $85.00$10.71 - $12.14
2$150.00 - $165.00$10.71 - $11.78
3$225.00 - $250.00$10.71 - $11.90

Suitable For

Bistro MD
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One
Magic Kitchen
Meals For Families
Meals For Kids
Meals For Seniors
Meals For One

Compare Meal Options

Bistro MD
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals
Magic Kitchen
Vegetarian Meals
Vegan Meals
Paleo Meals
Keto Meals
Low-Carb Meals
Low-Fat Meals
Meals For Diabetics
Gluten-Free Meals
Organic Meals
Weight Loss Meals

Compare Sample Meals

Bistro MD
Magic Kitchen

Compare Extras

Bistro MD
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace
Magic Kitchen
A La Carte Menu
Gift Cards
Marketplace

Compare Ratings

Bistro MD
FINAL RATING
9.7/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price
Magic Kitchen
FINAL RATING
8.7/10
Meal Options
Variety
Nutritional Value
Portion Size
Flexibility
Price

Compare Customer Reviews

Bistro MD
  • Submitted By Thomas Hartnett on 06/18/2019
    Stay Away from Bistro MD: high cost, too many wired recipes, total lack of customer service. Total rip off. One star rating because you can’t go any lower.
  • Submitted By Courtney on 05/10/2019
    I ordered a vegetarian meal plan for my sister for a week to help her out. She doesn't like cooking, so I thought this was the best of both worlds! Wrong! The delivery was late, so when she finally received the food, they were lukewarm. Out of feeling bad for me, she tried a meal and got really sick afterwards. I got ahold of them (as did she), and they agreed to send her a replacement week. I asked if I needed to go through and choose the meals again since she was vegetarian. They said, "No, there is no need. She will be receiving the same food that she ordered last week." Wrong again. The package arrived a day late again, but thankfully they weren't in as bad shape as the first time. But 4 out of the 10 meals had seafood in them, so she wasn't able to eat them. I emailed them AGAIN asking to go through a refund process because I was fed up. They tried to send more replacement meals but I declined and asked for a refund instead. "Well you know that our vegetarian meal plan actually includes seafood, so that's what we sent her." After explaining to them that I tried to warn them that she doesn't eat meat, they finally said, "Well okay. But we can only issue a refund for those 4 meals." Whatever. I told them that it would be $36 for the four meals. They sent an email days later saying, "We have issued a refund of $30. Please wait (so and so) days until this reflects in your account." I emailed back AGAIN telling them that they did not refund me the right amount."Good Afternoon, ________.Thank you for your email. It would be my pleasure to assist you.I would be happy to check into the total amount of your refund, however, I am not able to locate an account with your name or email address.If you can please provide the full shipping name, and delivery address, so we can proceed. I look forward to your response.We wish you success along your journey towards life-transforming wellness."I sent the information they needed. That was a month ago. Do you think they actually refunded me the rest? Or even followed up with me after this? Nope. I am so over this company. They are willing to work with you if they think they will still get your business. But when they sniff out the first scent of you leaving, they put their worst representative on the phone. I'm sticking with HelloFresh from now on. I have yet to receive a bad box from them.
  • Submitted By Maggie on 04/30/2019
    In 2 weeks I had 3 decent meals and the rest were plain lousy or absolutely inedible. Very disappointed.
  • Submitted By John Attenbury on 06/07/2018
    This is really good food made with high quality ingredients. I like that it's a dr designed plan, as my dr told me that I need to lose 30 pounds to fall into a healthy(er) BMI. Couldn't be more pleased with the customer service, as I initially thought that I wasn't going to be home in time to accept my delivery (traveling for work) but they helped make sure that it was taken care of so I would be home when it arrived. Really pleased overall. Maybe 3-4 meals on the menu were terrible, but the rest were very good. I'm a long term customer for sure.One last thing... Don't get at all what the review from Nan says about the meals having artificial ingredients and loaded with preservatives. Was surprised and pleased that I could easily identify the ingredients on the labels. I didn't see anything that fits the bill that Nan described, but maybe I didn't get the same meals? Really doubt that my experience and theirs could be be that different on such a specific thing as quality of ingredients.
Magic Kitchen
  • Submitted By Barbara F. on 06/03/2018
    Explored this option for my mother who needs low sodium meals. While prices are not cheap, they are also not unreasonable when one considers also the time needed to shop, prep + cook the same kind of meal at home. Everything super fresh and arrived in good condition. Just heat n eat. Highly recommend.
  • Submitted By Ruth Cross on 12/14/2017
    I only order from time to time, it’s delicious and there are so many options but I can’t afford to order very often.
  • Submitted By Danny Walter on 12/10/2017
    I like that I can build my own meals and I save quite a lot with the discounts, so if you pick your meals carefully, you get a great meal at the price of a sandwich.
  • Submitted By Grace Russell, on 07/11/2017
    Very, very good. The food doesn’t taste like when it’s freshly prepared, but you can’t expect that much from frozen meals. And it’s still tasty.

Winner

BistroMD prepares meals designed for your individual weight loss program and delivers them to your door. A team led by a board-certified medical practitioner with more than 20 years of experience creates the perfect combination of nutritionally optimized and tasty meals for your diet plan. All you have to do is finally enjoy losing weight.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices. Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.
Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.